The Western Formula Essay, Research Paper
A seemingly traditional approach towards the Western frontier is the reason for John Cawelti s assessment from The Six-Gun Mystique. His description of the Western formula being far easier to define than that of the detective story may clearly be a paradigm for many authors, but not particularly for Stephen Crane. The standards Cawelti has set forth for a successful Western is quite minimal by thought, but at the same time relevant. Crane signifies a different perspective to these standards. Crane s thoughts for the use of the Western formula are just approaches towards the west, from the introductory setting to the coarse grin one cowboy would make towards another. These do not in fact relate to Cawelti s Western formula. Crane s deviation from the formula western signifies his deeper approach towards issues such as human existence and morality the ethical code that we follow for success. Crane perhaps does this because he personally finds more significance in the inner meaning of an issue rather than its surfacing argument.
Cawelti s Western formula holds a strong assumption that men are assertive and women are insignificant. He is standardizing the black and white of the West. There is an unequivocal struggle between good and evil and guns and violence can only solve that. Jane Tompkins standpoint on a Western seems to be a middle ground between Cawelti and Crane. She recognizes that violence is a central theme to a Western, but as well explains how we think of violence. In this day of age, we as a society have prohibited violence as a means of solving problems Crane does not directly follow this in his stories, but definitely questions it. Cawelti on the other hand marks violence as the only answer another black and white circumstance.
This radical discrepancy between the sense of eroding masculinity and the view of America as a great history of men against the wilderness has created the need for a means of symbolic expression of masculine potency in an unmistakable way. This means is the gun, particularly the six-gun (Crane 299).
Tompkins makes us aware that a stereotypical Western will hold two men as the key factors and a struggle between them. Where Crane tries describing macho cowboys in The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky, he directs more of the theme towards the role of a woman and how it plays against male violence. This is ambiguous towards Cawelti s feeling for women to be insignificant to a Western life as if they are just there for minimal diversity and show.
Stephen Crane shapes The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky, entirely around the bride and how she will enter a new life in the small town of Yellow Sky. The only instance of a possible Western formula is as a cowboy by the name of Scratchy Wilson points a gun at Jack Potter, the husband and town marshal. However, when Scratchy realizes that Potter had gotten married, he put down his gun and walked away. He moved a pace backward, and his arm, with the revolver, dropped to his side (Crane 311). This contradicts the black and white situation Cawelti would expect. The fight between good and evil had risen and it must be taken care of through violence, perhaps a draw. This did not happen though, and that is why Crane s perspective towards a Western is quite far from the formula. Apparently, the moral and ethical code that Crane acknowledges in his stories is his main concern. The story can climax, and desire be sated, only if the moral applause meter reads way of the scale in the hero s favor (Tompkins 236). Crane describes Scratchy Wilson as a man when sober cannot hurt a fly, but while intoxicated will hurt anything. The black and white issue turns gray by giving the villain a heart.
Throughout the entire story, the ideas of violence arise, but the actions upon them do not. This is a very bad path Crane chose if he was looking to depict a formula western. If this story was to follow the standards Cawelti has set forth, Potter would most likely be dead and Scratchy Wilson would be marking another notch on his gun belt. The macho male attitude has been covered by the marks moral principles. Cawelti feels there is no room for that in a formula western. Tompkins feels, This is a moment of moral ecstasy.
Married! He was not a student of chivalry; it was merely that in the presence of this foreign condition he was a simple child of the earlier plains. He picked up his starboard revolver, and, placing both weapons in their holsters, he went away (Crane 312).
Crane s divergence from Cawelti s standards pattern entirely away from this formula western, however, do not seem to hurt the overall story instead helps in providing a variation of how a Western may be written.
In another story by Crane, The Blue Hotel, the Western formula can hardly be considered. The first half of this entire story is based in a hotel, bed and breakfast type of inn where there are several men sitting around a table playing a card game. However, none except for one is a cowboy, and the setting does not relate too much to the West, besides their slang vocabulary. In ways, it seems that some random person, who not only did not live in the West, but also did not live in the country, could have written this story. It was so far off basis of a Western that all one could think is that there are random people sitting and playing cards. The interesting part is the basis of a foreigner. A crazy Swede thinks that he is in a rough place, and if he does anything wrong, he will be killed. Cawelti would never consider this for a Western. This first part held no Western significance.
The second half of this story had a more Western feel to it, as the nutty Swede introduced in the beginning of the story enters the town bar. As the Swede talks too confidently he ends up getting killed, by a gambler, not even a cowboy.
What! You won t drink with me, you little dude? I ll make you then! I ll make you! The Swede had grasped the gambler frenziedly at the throat, and was dragging him fro his chair. There was a great tumult, and then was seen a long blade in the hand of the gambler. It shot forward, and a human body, this citadel virtue, wisdom, power, was pierced as easily as if it had been a melon. The Swede fell with a cry of supreme astonishment (Crane 334).
The fact that there was no brawl, but just a simple murder, no struggle between evil and good contradicts the formula western. This was not a black and white, hero and villain situation, rather an annoyance. The entire story had complete irrelevance to a stereotypical Western except for the fact that there were three daughters of the hotel owner, Scully, and they made food. That could be the only potential relation to Cawelti s feel on womens insignificance.
It seems that Tompkins is the interpreter between Crane and Cawelti. Cawelti defines the standards and Crane seems to contradict them. Tompkins jumps in and explains what Crane has done and why it is not done like Cawelti. Now she does not directly acknowledge either writer, but clearly works for both.
So instead of offering you a moral, I call your attention to a moment of righteous ecstasy, the moment when you know you have the moral advantage of your adversary, the moment of murderousness. It s a moment when there s still time top stop. There s still time to reflect, there s still time to recall what happened in High Noon, there s still time to say: I don t care who s right or who s wrong. There has to be some better way to live (Tompkins 239).
Другие работы по теме:
Tshapes Essay Research Paper Looking at the
T-shapes Essay, Research Paper Looking at the 9-9 grid below and the T-shape drawn on it, The total number of the numbers on the inside of the T-shape is called the T-total
Grants Essay Research Paper grantsThe national level
Grants Essay, Research Paper grants The national level was able to achieve their goals through the local level by using categorical grant in aid programs. These grants were given out with certain objectives that had to be met and specific criteria would have to be followed. This categorical grant in aid had two parts to it.
The Passage For Nietzsche On Religion Rhetorical
Devices Essay, Research Paper Following is an excerpt from Twilight of the Idols by Nietzsche. The most general formula at the basis of every religion and morality is: ‘Do this and this, refrain from this and this – and you will be happy! Otherwise….’ Every morality, every religion is this imperative – I call it the great original sin of reason, immortal unreason.
Western Front Essay Research Paper On 3rd
Western Front Essay, Research Paper On 3rd August, 1914, German troops crossed the Belgian border in the narrow gap between Holland and France. The German First and Second Armies swept aside the small Belgian Army and by 20th August had occupied Brussels.
Design Essay Research Paper The good design
Design Essay, Research Paper The good design nuances of Colors magazine ?lend? well to the Macsystems advert. Maybe this comes from the similar design goal that a magazine and advert
GUIA DE EXAMEN PARCIAL DE EXCEL 97
Essay, Research Paper 1. Que es una hoja de calculo?Es una ayuda para el ser humano para poder hacer c?lculos diversos eintroducir formulas. 2. Que nombre recibe el cursor de una hoja de calculo?Celda activa.
Environmental Archaeology Essay Research Paper IF
Environmental Archaeology Essay, Research Paper IF we want to know how humans functioned we must know what their world was like ? thus environmental reconstruction Geomorphical and biological processes occurring
Theo Essay Research Paper SummaryThis article shows
Theo Essay, Research Paper Summary This article shows us how Christianity has changed throughout the ages. We can see how Jesus has become the dominant figure in today?s western culture. It tells of how Christianity differed with the teaching of the ancient Romans, and how God wanted us to live our lives. People stopped being afraid of death and their values were changing, becoming much different than those of the Romans.
Judith Herrin Carolingian Innovation From The
Formation Of Christendom Essay, Research Paper ?Through efforts Charlemagne?s father, Pippin, that dynasty dominated majority Western Europe ? strong position, Aquitaine problematic, continues his father, Cahrles Martel?s
Algebra Essay Research Paper Determine and Apply
Algebra Essay, Research Paper Determine and Apply a Formula My topic for this assignment is was to determine the amount of people possible to cross a crosswalk during the time of the crosswalk?s walking symbols. To calculate this I made an algebraic equation to support my idea, and an example to support my equation.
Rockies Essay Research Paper The Rocky Mountains
Rockies Essay, Research Paper The Rocky Mountains are a great chain of rugged mountain ranges in western North America, extending from central New Mexico to northwestern British Columbia, about 2000 miles. The Rockies are boardered on the east by the Great Plains and on the west by the Great Basin and Rocky Mountain Trench.
Antigone The Hero Essay Research Paper Antigone
Antigone The Hero Essay, Research Paper Antigone the Hero Antingone is the heroine of western drama, and the play bears her name rather than Creon?s. I believe this statement to be true. Not only because Antigone is the Heroine, but because the story also revolves around her. If not for the conflict of disobeying her uncle, the story wouldn’t have a pourpose.
GDP As A Measure Of The Economy
Essay, Research Paper GDP As a Measure of the Economy The GDP is not a sufficient gauge of how the nation’s economy is doing. The GDP is a sum of the monetary value of what has been produced in the nation in the past year. The formula for calculating the GDP ignores a large percentage of the activities that transpire in the nation’s economy.
Emmas Dilemma Essay Research Paper EmmasDilemma In
Emma?s Dilemma Essay, Research Paper Emma?s Dilemma In my investigation I am going to investigate the number of different arrangements of letters in a word. e.g. Tim Is one arrangementMit Is another First I am going to investigate how many different
Indonesian Gamelan Essay Research Paper Gamelan concerts
Indonesian Gamelan Essay, Research Paper Gamelan concerts are mysterious and enticing. The sound, which come from the multi-performed, hitting of the copper instruments, makes any listener become aware of a story line of some sort. This music is exotic and that is what it has going for it in the western world.
American Revolution Essay Research Paper Q
American Revolution Essay, Research Paper Q: Explain why Japan reacted to western ideas by adopting a policy of isolation. How did this reaction to outside influences effect Japans development over the next few centuries.
Kuwait Essay Research Paper Kuwait seeking to
Kuwait Essay, Research Paper Kuwait, seeking to avoid looking like a puppet of outside powers, did not call on the United States or other non-Arab powers for support. For their part, the U.S. and other Western governments generally expected that at worst Iraq would seize some border area to intimidate Kuwait, so they avoided being pulled into the dispute.
Women In India Essay Research Paper The
Women In India Essay, Research Paper The Changing Role of Women in India Women in India are beginning to follow the direction that the women of the Western world took more than eighty years ago; demanding treatment as human equals. However, it has become more and more evident as the revolution ages that Indian women may have to adapt the Western feminist method to their very traditional and religious culture.
Typical Westerns Essay Research Paper justyn dallmannTypical
Typical Westerns Essay, Research Paper justyn dallmann Typical Westerns I think that Stephen Crane used alto of ideas from typical writings. I say this because some of the things were not typical but many of them were. This made the story unique because it wasn’t the same as most other westerns but in some ways it was the same.
Sliver Oxide Lab Essay Research Paper Sliver
Sliver Oxide Lab Essay, Research Paper Sliver Oxide LabPurpose: To find the chemical formula for Silver Oxide and to improve student’s skills with lab equipment. Hazards: Heat/FlameMidly hazordous chemicalsMaterials:Small Crucible and means of suspending it above a flameBunson BurnerAccurate scale in gramsTongsProcedure:Place the crucible on your scale and record it’s weight when empty.
The Republic By Plato 427
– 347 B.C.) Essay, Research Paper The Republic is one of the foundational writings of Western philosophy and civilization. We see Platonic thought and Socratic methodology still vitally evolving in today’s world. Dialectic
Backtitration Essay Research Paper Backtitration Work
Backtitration Essay, Research Paper Backtitration: Work to be done: To find out the atomic mass of a substance using a method called backtitration. Chemicals and apparatus:Magnesium Beaker Glass Burette Distilled water Methylred 0.5 M sodium hydroxide, NaOH1.0 M hydrochloric acid, HCl Lab-work: The name of the experiment explains the way of doing it quite well.
Poison Essay Research Paper PoisonA Game Instructions
Poison Essay, Research Paper Poison A Game Instructions: Start off with ten counters. Each team will take a turn, taking one or two counters each time. The team that must take the final counter, also known as the poison counter, loses.
T E Lawrence Essay Research Paper Colonel
T E Lawrence Essay, Research Paper Colonel T. E. Lawrence, known as Lawrence of Arabia, was a guerrilla leader in the Arab Revolt of 1916-18, which expelled the Turks from western Arabia and
Persia Essay Research Paper Influence of Islamic
Persia Essay, Research Paper Influence of Islamic Art The art of Europe, or ‘Western art’ is of a totally different type and style as what is known as ‘Islamic art’. It is difficult to have samples of both together in one place, observe the patterns of one and the narrative form of the other and say, “Islamic art influenced the art of Italy”.
Dance Essay Research Paper Throughout the course
Dance Essay, Research Paper Throughout the course of human history, dance has been a part of cultures around the world. The purpose and style of dance varies from culture to culture. Perhaps in this
International Relations Realism Essay Research Paper In
International Relations: Realism Essay, Research Paper In the discipline of International Relations realism, which developed as a reaction to idealism during the Cold War, has become the dominant school of thought . Realism makes power the currency of international politics. Realist argue that by accumulating power states can ensure the security of the population within the state.
Globalization Essay Research Paper GlobalizationGlobalization over the
Globalization Essay, Research Paper Globalization Globalization over the past twenty has become an issue in many countries. This industrialization of second and third world countries by Western Civilization creates many opportunities for the inhabitants. Not only does it expand trading markets, but also promotes productivity and efficiency; thus improving the country and integrating it into the industrial world.