Njsp Profiling Essay, Research Paper
NEW JERSEY STATE POLICE RACIAL PROFILING
SEAN SILVERS
PROF. ROMANO
11/6/00
Racial profiling is a law enforcement strategy that encourages police officers to stop and question African Americans simply because of their race. Although not raised as a major issue in the courtroom during the trial of the four police officers who shot Amadou Diallo (who were acquitted in February), racial profiling is often employed by police, officially and unofficially, and was likely a factor in the police shooting of Diallo.
Racial profiling took off during the highly publicized explosion of crack cocaine in inner-city neighborhoods in the 1980s, which bolstered the perception of drugs as a black problem — even though statistics showed most cocaine users were white. Drug enforcement agencies began using racial profiling to “sweep” neighborhoods and in arresting disproportionate numbers of African Americans for drug related offenses.
A profile of potential drug users and sellers was developed to assist policemen in picking out and questioning likely offenders. These profiles continue to be used by law enforcement in combating crime.
Recent high profile cases and studies of racial profiling in New Jersey and Maryland prompted Congress to introduce the Traffic Stops Statistics Study Act of 1999, directing Attorney General Janet Reno to conduct a nationwide study of the race of drivers who are stopped by law enforcement. Congress is expected to vote on the bill later this year.
The current debate on racial profiling has been tied to allegations of police brutality and institutional racism. In response to one shooting of an unarmed black man by a police officer, video cameras were installed in police cruisers in Montgomery and Prince George’s counties in Maryland. A four-year investigation of alleged police brutality in Montgomery County by the Department of Justice resulted in demands that officers must ask drivers their age, sex and race, and then compile that data for regular reports as a way of monitoring future police behavior toward minority suspects.
The bad side of Racial profiling is that it is inherently biased in its basic assumption that blacks are more likely to commit crimes than other minorities or whites. This assumption has precipitated numerous, documented incidents of police brutality against minorities on New Jersey and Maryland roads, and is certain to have done the same elsewhere. When racial profiling is used as a tactic in law enforcement, law-abiding African Americans justly fear for their safety and freedom.
Racial profiling defeats its purpose by fueling mistrust and anger in black communities toward law enforcement because the policy encourages institutionalized racism in police forces nationwide.
Some believe that racial profiling makes statistical sense. African Americans commit a disproportionately high percentage of the crimes that draw the attention of the police. While some innocent people may face police stops because of racial profiling, it is a small price to pay for safe streets. Crime rates in the U.S. have decreased significantly over the last decade, in large part because racial profiling has become an important part of a more aggressive law enforcement policy.
There are some statistics that need to be examined while discussing racial profiling. Between 1992 and 1996, 58 percent of all car jackers were african american. African Americans only make up 12 percent of the population. African American make up 13 percent of the country?s drug users. 74 percent of all criminals sentenced to prison for drug possession are african american (Carrilli). It is human nature for a police officer to want to search a suspicious character. The statistics prove that blacks tend to be involved in more suspicious activity then many of the other races.
In 1998, Governor Christian Whitman fired Col. Carl William’s from the position of Superintendent of the State Police for comments he had made on the issue of Racial profiling. In response to a strong outcry from the black community, Whitman hired Carson Dumbar as the new superintendent. In a July article of USA Today, Governor Whitman was found to be a violator of racial profiling. ?
For months the New Jersey governor has spearheaded an effort to end racial profiling by the state police she once defended against charges that many officers systematically stopped people for no reason other than the color of their skin. But her position changed after the state’s attorney general released a report last year that concluded racial profiling had been a common practice among state police.
Since then Whitman has pushed for a major reform of the force and become a vocal opponent of racial profiling. Her flip-flop angered many state troopers, but won her few converts among the black activists who had long argued that New Jersey’s state police engaged in racial profiling. Even so, as she pressed for reforms, Whitman seemed to have a legitimate claim on the moral high ground.
But what once looked like an act of political courage began to take on the appearance of a disingenuous political retreat when a 4-year-old picture of the governor frisking a young black man recently surfaced. The 1996 photo shows Whitman searching the man, who is spread-eagled against a graffiti covered wall in Camden, N.J. The encounter occurred as she was riding with a state police unit that had been sent into the South Jersey city to help reduce crime ? and came after an officer had searched the man and determined that he was unarmed and not in possession of any contraband (Wickman).
To try and deal with the racial profiling problem, Governor Whitman and Col. Dumbar have come up with a plan to diversify the pool of candidates of state police. New Jersey and the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) and a class of unhired trooper applicants have settled a four-year-old lawsuit against the State Police by agreeing to a plan to emphasize both stringent educational standards and the need for diversity in the ranks. According to the agreement, signed by the State and both the national NAACP and its New Jersey Chapter, State Police has made a commitment to aggressively recruit a diverse pool of qualified applicants to take the written trooper qualification test.
Specifically, New Jersey will now recruit and select State Police applicants who have 60 college credit hours and two years or more of life experience “indicating the maturity of the applicant.”
???????Such life experience,Attorney General Farmer said, need not be limited to police or military service, as was the case previously. It can also include two years of satisfactory employment that brings desirable skills into the corps. The new eligibility standard is in place for recruiting the 119th State Police class (Farmer, Jr.). Although these standards will diversify the pool of candidates, it will also lower the standards for the qualified applicants.
Racial profiling is a widely debated issue. Is it wrong for a police officer to stop someone because of their race? The answer is yes. But the fact remains that the statistics show minorities have a high occurrence of crime. If a police officer profiles a person because of their appearance, they are just doing what they are trained for. It is a law enforcement officer?s job to recognize suspicious activity. In some cases his or her life may depend on it.
We live in a society where the community wants to be Utopian. We want crime to go down, but we don?t want to attack the source where it comes from. Police officers perform dangerous tasks. They take precautions that many of us don?t understand. Some times it may cause inconvenience for those of us who are effected by their duties. That is the price we have to pay to live in a safe society.
Carrilli,Silvio, ?Are Racial Profiles a Legitimate Tool for Law
Enforcement?, Speakout, April 20 2000.
Farmer, Jr., ?New Jersey NAACP Lawsuit Settlement?, New Jersey Department of LAw and Public Safety, March 1 2000.
Wickman, DeWayne, ?Governor Whitman?s Racial Profiling Flip is a Flop?, USA Today, July 21 2000.
Другие работы по теме:
September 11 Essay Research Paper During the
September 11 Essay, Research Paper During the summer of tenth grade, I took a number theory course at Johns Hopkins University with students from Alaska, California, and Bogota, Colombia. My attendance of the New Jersey Governor’s School in the Sciences is another accomplishment that exemplifies my dedication to knowledge.
Lennie Lenape Essay Research Paper he Lenape
Lennie Lenape Essay, Research Paper he Lenape Indians were the first people to live in what is now called New Jersey. The Lenape Indians lived in parts of Delaware, Pennsylvana, and New Jersey.
Espanol Essay Research Paper Yo naci en
Espanol Essay, Research Paper Yo naci en Nueve Jersey, pero vivi en Nueva York. Cuando tenia tres anos me mude a nuevo a Nueve Jersey. En el verano iba con mis padres a la India a visitabamos mis
Racial Profiling Essay Research Paper Despite the
Racial Profiling Essay, Research Paper Despite the civil rights victories of 30 years ago, official racial prejudice is still reflected throughout the criminal justice system. For people of color in cities large and small across this nation, north and south, east and west, Jim Crow “justice” is alive and well.
Casino Gambling Approaching Rural America Essay Research
Paper Since the dawn of casinos, casino gambling was located mainly in Reno and Las Vegas, Nevada, and in Atlantic City, New Jersey. But now newer casinos are spread out across the United States, from Connecticut to California. Most are located on Indian reservations and the rest in rural areas of the United States.
Piedmont Essay Research Paper One of the
Piedmont Essay, Research Paper One of the physical regions in New Jersey is a piedmont. The Atlantic Coastal Plain Piedmont Ridge, and Valley region and high land have different land. They are also regions. Some of New Jersey s biggest cities are in Piedmonts. Some piedmont cities in New Jersey are Newark, Jersey City, Elizabeth, East Orange, Hoboken, Passaic, Clifton, Paterson, and Union City.
Satire Essay Research Paper With all of
Satire Essay, Research Paper With all of the problems in today s society, it is great to know that we have one great thing going for us. That would be the talented men and women of our government. The powerful president, senators, congressmen, governors, mayors, and other politicians work together to keep this country it s very best.
Congressional Project Essay Research Paper Between these
Congressional Project Essay, Research Paper Between these two great men Steve Rothman and Robert Torricelli. I have learned a lot about congressmen and politics but I am going to go into both of their biography and tell you a little about them.
Women In Politics Essay Research Paper During
Women In Politics Essay, Research Paper During the revolutionary era, American leaders decided to use economic boycotts in their struggle against Britain. The goal of these boycotts was to stop the purchase of imported goods
New Jersey Vs TLO Essay Research Paper
Christopher D. Monroe II New Jersey Vs. T.L.O. Facts of the Case On March 7, 1985 T.L.O. and another student were found smoking in the woman?s bathroom. They were then taken to see the Assistant Principal, Mr. Choplick, and were questioned about smoking
Racial Profiling Essay Research Paper The topic
Racial Profiling Essay, Research Paper The topic of racial profiling amongst minority individuals in the state of New Jersey has been a heated issue for the past several years. This department has been charged with numerous allegations of racism and is the main focus for racial based events in police departments nationwide.
Stephen Crane Biography Essay Research Paper Stephen
Stephen Crane Biography Essay, Research Paper Stephen Crane Biography Stephen Crane was born in Newark, New Jersey on November 1, 1871. Stephen was the last of 14 children. His father a Methodist Minister died when he was nine. Stephen never cared much for school. He became well known as a social critic, journalist, and as a poet.
John Bardeen Essay Research Paper Bardeen John
John Bardeen Essay, Research Paper Bardeen, John 1908-91, American physicist; b. Madison, Wis. He was known for his studies of semiconductivity and other aspects of SOLID-STATE PHYSICS. The first
TLO Vs New Jersey Essay Research Paper
TLO vs. New Jersey: When Is The Constitution Invalid? In the case of New Jersey vs. TLO, I rule in favor of the petitioner, the state of New Jersey. In this case, I found no reason in the claims made by
Allen Ginsberg Essay Research Paper What exactly
Allen Ginsberg Essay, Research Paper What exactly does it mean to be American? What are the boundaries of freedom and liberty? Do we have the freedom to speak from the heart? Allen Ginsberg believed so, and he did just that.
Racial Profiling Unfair To The Innocent Essay
, Research Paper Racial Profiling: Unfair to the Innocent The issue of racial profiling in America is one of great importance to the future of American society. This issue fairly new, in terms of being recognized is old in its ways. Racism and stereotyping are issues that date back to hundreds of years ago. Racial profiling in America is one that needs to be addressed by the government and society if we ever want America to truly be, “The Land of The Free.” One of the main examples of racial profiling is called DWB (Driving While Black).
Racial Profiling Essay Research Paper Racial profiling
Racial Profiling Essay, Research Paper Racial profiling is a law enforcement strategy that encourages police officers to stop and question African-Americans simply because of their race. Employers and government agencies that require job applicants to list their “race” or “ethnicity” on employment and contracting applications perform racial profiling thousands of times every day.
Racial Profiling Essay Research Paper Lovely GregRacial
Racial Profiling Essay, Research Paper Lovely, Greg Racial Profiling/Police Officers Racial profiling, the act of categorizing, the targeting of a particular group of culture with a view towards labeling those individuals law enforcers believe are engaged in illegal activities. Does Racial Profiling still exist today? “He would kill me if I was the one going to the newspapers.” Words said by a newspaper editor threatened to death by Chicago Police officers.
Black Or White Essay Research Paper Black
Black Or White Essay, Research Paper Black or White Allison Davi Picture this hypothetical situation: A black man and a white man both driving during the day time. The white man is driving directly in front of the black man at 72 mph, clearly speeding, while the black man is driving at 46 mph, both in a 45 mph speed limit zone.
Ending Racial Profiling Essay Research Paper Ending
Ending Racial Profiling Essay, Research Paper Ending Racial Profiling The federal government should end racial profiling by requiring policemen and other law enforcement officers to keep detailed records of each individual they stop to question or search. These records should include the person?s race; the reason stopped; how long the car was detained; and whether a ticket was issued, the car searched, or any illegal goods or weapons were found when the traffic stop was made.
Internet Cookies Essay Research Paper Internet CookiesMost
Internet Cookies Essay, Research Paper Internet Cookies Most Experienced Web visitors and even new ones know about cookies these days. Cookies are small data files that are being put on your hard drive by Web sites when you visit them. They do this for many different reasons. One of them is to identify you as a distinctive visitor by identifying your Web browser software.
Legal Opinion For 8th Social Studies Essay
, Research Paper Legal Opinion A. I picked the side of New Jersey in the New Jersey vs. T.L.O case. The reason I picked that side is because the girl whas smoking on school grounds and she was not allowed to do that. Another reason is the teacher that found the girl smoking had the right to bring her to the Principals office, because she had a reason to.
Dna Profiling Essay Research Paper BILL BALAKIANDNA
Dna Profiling Essay, Research Paper BILL BALAKIAN DNA Profiling The testing and profiling of DNA in recent years has become 99.9% accurate in identifying a person, making it the most precise and most controversial means of identifying a person.
Prop 21 Essay Research Paper Prop 21Education
Prop 21 Essay, Research Paper Prop 21 Education is the best part of life. Education can evolve you into a better person. Education can prevent you from committing crimes and will lead you to a prosperous life. Proposition 21; The Gang Violence and Juvenile Crime Prevention Act aims to incarcerate disturbed youth rather then educate them.
Epa Essay Research Paper Environmental Protection AgencyThe
Epa Essay, Research Paper Environmental Protection AgencyThe Environmental Protection Agency, (EPA) in Edison, New Jersey is very successful in detecting and separating elements found in water. With it s expensive machinery and skilled workers the EPA proved to be successful in making New Jersey s drinking water safe.
Racial Profiling Essay Research Paper The United
Racial Profiling Essay, Research Paper The United States is not a healthy democracy The United States is not a healthy democracy. A basic requirement for any healthy democracy is its founding on the basic principle that all men are created equal. This means that man is judged on the fact that he is man, and only that.
Nostoc Information Essay Research Paper Scientific name
Nostoc Information Essay, Research Paper Scientific name – Kingdom- Monera, Phylum- Cyanobacteria, Class- NA, Order- nostocaler, Family- Nostocaceae, Genus- Nostoc, Species- caeruleumDescription- Nostoc is a one celled autotrophic organism that performs photosynthesis with out chloroplasts.
Thomas Edison Essay Research Paper Thomas EdisonOn
Thomas Edison Essay, Research Paper Thomas Edison On February 11, 1847, Thomas Edison was born in Milan Ohio. As a child, Edison always wondered why things happen and how things work. He was an extremely curious child and regarding his great curiosity, his teachers became irritated with him. Because of this, he began home schooling.