In 1998, a computer science major at Northeastern University, sat in front of his computer and started to create a program that would help the common man, spark controversy, and change and revolutionize the music industry. His name is Shawn Fanning, and his creation is Napster. Napster would forever change the way people would listen, share and acquire music, and the music industry would never again be the same.
Napster, launched early in 1999, allows Internet users to share and download MP3 files directly from any computer connected to the Napster network. The software is used by downloading a client program from the Napster site and then connecting to the network through this software, which allows sharing of MP3 files between all users connected to the network. While Napster does not condone copyright infringement, there is no opportunity in the software to stop this from happening, or for a percentage to be paid to artists whose songs are being duplicated for free.
Unlike similar file-sharing applications (such as Gnutella, or Freenet), Napster limits users to uploading/downloading of MP3 files only. These files are compressed wave (.wav) files. The advantage of MP3 files is that they are approximately one-tenth the size of the corresponding .wav file and can be close-to-CD-quality. It is for this reason that many artists, record labels and other music industry stakeholders are concerned by the MP3 file format and applications like Napster that simplify the sharing of copyrighted material.
The reaction from recording artists has been varied, but primarily anti-Napster. Hip-hop artist Jay-Z had this to say:
“I believe that if someone spends time making an album, putting their heart and soul into it, that their music shouldn’t be traded so freely.”
While mostly record industries and musicians have been in opposition to Napster, there are still artist that support the Napster cause, such artists include Dave Matthews, Madonna, Fred Durst, B.B. King, Dave Grohl, Ben Folds, U2’s Bono, and many more. Dave Matthews said this in defense of Napster:
“Napster: It is the future, in my opinion. That’s the way music is going to be communicated around the world. The most important thing now is to embrace it, and that was the spirit by which we did this co-promotion.”
In all this talk and controversy the first action to be taken against Napster was by the band Metallica. In April of this year, they sued Napster Inc for copyright infringement. The case was settled out of court when Napster agreed to ban some 300,000 users who had allegedly downloaded Metallica songs. After the ruling Metallica made the follwing statement:
“From day one our fight has always been to protect the rights of artists who chose not to have their music exploited without consent. The court’s decision validates this right and confirms that Napster was wrong in taking not only Metallica’s music but other artists who do not want to be a part of the Napster system and exploiting it without their approval.”
Again in June, Napster Inc. was sued for copyright infringement by The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), a trade group representing the US recording industry, alleging:
“Napster is… enabling and encouraging the illegal copying and distribution of copyrighted music”.
Napster claims that ‘Audio Home Recording Act’ permits copying of material for personal use, allows its uses to swap MP3s. The trail on Napster’s ‘swapping’ technology has turned into a debate over the 1st amendment. Napster claims that their product should be covered by freedom of speech, the industry argues back saying that the freedom of speech doesn’t cover copyrighted material.
Other artists and record labels have responded to Napster and similar applications in a more positive way, embracing the new technology rather than rejecting it. On their website, the Offspring says:
“MP3 technology and programs such as Napster [are] a vital and necessary means to promote music and foster better relationships with our fans.”
Interestingly enough, the Offspring’s last album, Americana, was made available online illegally before commercially released, yet it is the band’s best-selling album to date. Furthermore, a number of surveys have proven that Napster users actually buy more CDs, after ’sampling’ the songs online. It is this issue that is at the core of the RIAA lawsuit; whether Napster and similar programs will mean a drop in CD sales. Although Napster does challenge the traditional distribution of music (CDs, cassettes, etc), whether this should be viewed as a threat or simply a new medium to be exploited by the music industry is another issue. The fact that Napster is free and more convenient than visiting a record store makes it an appealing way to get music for consumers to get their music, rather than going to the local music store and coughing up 15 dollars.
The problem the record companies have is that there is no way of regulating who has access to the information, and hence no way of profiting from it. And that’s what it all comes down to, money. In a recent study of music stores in a 5-mile radius of 3,000 colleges, it showed that sales at those stores dropped 4 percent from January 1997 to March 2000, showing a significant decrease in sales in an area that would be more deeply affected by Napster, than normal cities. However record sales overall have shown a significant increase of 9 percent, in recent years. So the debate on whether the program Napster decreases industries sales still continues.
While Napster does allow music sharing to an extent that could theoretically destroy the retail music industry, stopping Napster will not stop all their problems. Record labels need to see this new technology not as a threat, but as a challenge. They need to come up with ideas to encourage people to buy CDs. According to John C. Dvorak of PC Magazine:
“By my calculations, the record companies can make as much or more money by abandoning their old business model and going with Napster’s. They should look at the numbers, do the math, and then form a massive joint venture with Napster…If 50 million users each paid $10 a month, or $120 a year, for unlimited access to everything, the service would gross $6 billion annually. Most of this money would be redistributed to the artists and labels, as determined by various contracts… The $6 billion a year would be right off the top and amount to almost pure profits, because the cost of distribution is nil. Possibly, the record companies and artists actually could make more money from this source than from conventional CDs.”
On February 20, 2001 Napster made proposals with major record labels to make this dream a reality. Napster’s proposal was to pay $1 billion dollars to the major labels, songwriters and independent labels and artists over 5 years in exchange for copyrights and legal use of their songs for file transfer. By doing so, Napster has stated that in the early summer, sometime around July, it will start to charge a monthly fee for usage of their product. Although no set fee has been set, it would be safe to say that the price range would be between $5-10 dollars. This is just one example of Napster’s attempt to change their current method to meet the satisfaction of both the consumer and the industry. There are many alternatives towards the reconfiguration of a product like Napster, to shut it completely down would be a tremendous tragedy.
Back when radio got popular, artists and record companies complained loudly that they would never make another dime, because everyone would listen to radio, and never buy a record. This didn’t happen, of course. It also didn’t happen when the Film Industry was afraid VCRs would wipe out their income from piracy. So, there is no reason to suppose a new stream of income for artists won’t appear to replace what might be lost through a service like Napster. However, so far there is no good model of how artists might get paid in a culture that gets it’s “musical content” for free. But a real truth is that even if the RIAA wins its battle against Napster, MP3 file sharing will not stop. As we speak, dozens of Napster clones are being created, and unlike Napster, these new creations cannot be shut down nor controlled. The RIAA should embrace Napster for what it’s worth, a tool, one to be used to distribute, advertise and create music. After all music is meant to be shared and expressed, not be held and controlled by the likes of the RIAA. Billy Joe Armstrong of Green Day once said about his music:
“I just want my music to be out, and that’s always been the main priority. It was never really about getting paid. It was just getting people to hear my music and say, ‘Hey, I like your song.’ So if Napster wants to put my song out so people can download it or whatever, let ‘em do it.”
Bibliography
Napster – 5/9/01
RIAA: Who We Are – 5/9/01
RIAA: Napster – 5/9/01
RIAA: On Deck / FAQ on Napster and Digital Music – 5/9/01
The Offspring: MP3 Technology and Napster – 5/9/01
Smith, Tony. “Napster Boosts CD sales: survey.” The Register – 5/9/01
“Napster not Protected by Copyright Law.” USA Today – 5/9/01
Cohen, Adam, “A Crisis of Content”, TIME Magazine, 10/2/00
Dvorak, John C., “Do the Napster Math”, PC Magazine, 5/1/01
Greenfield, Karl T., “Meet the Napster”, TIME Magazine, 10/2/00
Другие работы по теме:
Being A Musician Essay Research Paper Music
Being A Musician Essay, Research Paper Music is an ever-changing style. People listen to music of all types everyday. What most people don’t know is what it takes to make that music they listen to. Today’s music is a lot different than music prior to the 80’s. Machines can almost do all the work for some of the songs you hear on the radio today, but there are still some groups who do it the real way.
Folk Vs Rock Essay Research Paper Music
Folk Vs Rock Essay, Research Paper Music is the way we speak, who we are, where we came from, what we feel, the things we remember, and music often communicates the things we are unable to. I have an extensive group of friends. The biggest difficulty I?ve noticed about this is our music tastes. Riding in the car is often like attending a court hearing over control over the c.d. player.
Music Everywhere Essay Research Paper The rhythm
Music Everywhere Essay, Research Paper The rhythm flows through one s head. It can be viewed many ways, but effects everyone differently. This naturally occurring and man made miracle can t be summed up in just one short essay. Yet many have and will continue to try. It s carried across millions of airwaves everyday.
Guatier Essay Research Paper Due to the
Guatier Essay, Research Paper Due to the curriculum of Spring Ridge Middle School, all the students are required to take a music class of their choice. I signed up for mine in the 7th grade, but since I can’t carry a tune very well I decided a guitar class would be the way to go. I’m not musical and besides in Elementary School, this is the only music class that I can vaguely remember taking.
Day The Music Died Essay Research Paper
The Day the Music Died, Again I think about the loss we have endured, I think about our future, I think about the hate in this world, and it all makes me cry. September 11th was my 17th birthday, and I was sitting on the line at the DMV, listening to my car radio as it all happened. The music actually died that day. Not a single station played a song; instead they all talked of the horror unfolding before us.
Rock N Roll Essay Research Paper From
Rock N Roll Essay, Research Paper From jazz and boogie of the thirties moved popular music away from the light entertainment of the theater toward a more exiting and dance oriented style that made the swing era a golden age. Do to jazz moving into rhythm and blues black people were recognized for talents in music and dance.
Music Essay Research Paper 3
Music Essay, Research Paper 3. J.S. Bach was an organist and choirmaster for Lutheran churches. Bach devoted his life to composing music for the church services. He wrote magnificent music for the organ, for choral groups, for clavier and harpsichord, for orchestra, and for small groups of instruments.
Music Writer Essay Research Paper Music WriterThe
Music Writer Essay, Research Paper Music Writer The job of being a music writer entails many things. As most people believe, they do more then criticize artists work. In an email interview between Steven Ward, and David McGee (a music writer), David tells of how he works for BarnesandNoble as a country music editor.
Enfluening OF Music Essay Research Paper This
Enfluening OF Music Essay, Research Paper This Essay is about how music can influence the emotions and effects of a person. I will be giving you precentages. I will also be giving you quotes of students
How American Music Has Changed Over The
Past 50 Years Essay, Research Paper How American Music Has Changed Over The Past 50 Years People have often wondered if music has always been around. Well, to answer that question I did some research to find out where our music originated. Our first reliable music records came from the Greeks and the Romans.
Music Essay Research Paper Tonight I went
Music Essay, Research Paper Tonight I went to my first concert. I saw the Duquesne University Wind Symphony and Symphonic Band at the Carnegie Music Hall in Oakland. Robert C. Cameron conducted both the Symphony and Band. The Wind Symphony began the night by playing the Dedication Overture and then proceeded on to what was my favorite piece of the concert, Old American Country Set.
Indonesian Gamelan Essay Research Paper Gamelan concerts
Indonesian Gamelan Essay, Research Paper Gamelan concerts are mysterious and enticing. The sound, which come from the multi-performed, hitting of the copper instruments, makes any listener become aware of a story line of some sort. This music is exotic and that is what it has going for it in the western world.
Hip Hop Essay Research Paper Music AppreciationHipHop
Hip Hop Essay, Research Paper Music Appreciation Hip-Hop is one of the newest forms of music. It has expanded and is now the most popular form of music for people ages 11-25. In the last 2 years, hip-hop is the most lucrative form of music. It has sold billions of records and has made record companies billions of dollars.
Napster Vs Riaa Essay Research Paper Napster
Napster Vs Riaa Essay, Research Paper Napster vs. Music Industry Napster is an ongoing controversy on the Web. Napster is a software program that allows anyone to find their favorite music by connecting them to the computers of millions of other users. It is the simplest way to find the MP3s they want, whenever they want, and share them with the world’s largest community of music lovers.
Medieval Music Essay Research Paper Music in
Medieval Music Essay, Research Paper Music in the middle ages is similar to the music that we listen to today in the way that there are many different types of music for different types of people. There were many types of music in the middle ages including Slavic, Jewish, Popular, middle eastern, and many other types of religious music as well as music for entertainment.
Napster Debate Essay Research Paper Napster DebateFor
Napster Debate Essay, Research Paper Napster Debate For a project in college eighteen-year old Shawn Fanning wrote a program for a way to download music off the internet. He later put the program on the internet and Napster was born. Napster is a program that allows you to download music on the internet. Since this program is free, many people have downloaded Napster.
Slow Dance Essay Research Paper S L
Slow Dance Essay, Research Paper S L O W D A N C E: *BR* *br* Have you ever watched kids*br* on a merry-go-round*br* Or listened to the rain*br* slapping on the ground?*br**br*
Irish Clasical Musiv Essay Research Paper To
Irish Clasical Musiv Essay, Research Paper To most individuals Irish music brings a certain type of music to mind, jigs, reels hornpipes various types of dancing music. It may also bring to mind the common pub songs regarding war, love, sadness and of course emigration. Turlough O’carolan introduced a different flavor of Irish music that in some ways is still seen today.
Napster Essay Research Paper There are many
Napster Essay, Research Paper There are many different controversies when consulting the topic on Napster. Napster is a computer program that lets people download mp3 music files from other people with the program. Lots of people and music companies believe that this is bad and Napster should be stopped or should charge people.
Rock Music Essay Research Paper ROCK
Rock Music Essay, Research Paper ROCK Rock does mean any relatively hard mass of mineral or petrified matter, or stone, but it is also a type of music. Rock is a type of music in which teens have always been associated with. Rock music has been around since the early to mid nineteen fifties and has emerged and changed throughout the years.
Transdental Meditation Essay Research Paper The Meditation
Transdental Meditation Essay, Research Paper The Meditation exercise that we performed in class was refreshing. It cleared my mind of all stress that day. As I lay on the mat, I had no idea I was that tensed. It was somewhat hard to imagine a flame below my navel. The music in the background was relaxing It was flicking with the flame in my mind.
Country Music Essay Research Paper Country MusicToday
Country Music Essay, Research Paper Country Music Today, many people in the United States listen to country music. People have almost always listen to this type of music, from early rebels, to the families of today. The topic of true country music usually remains the same in all songs. The country atmosphere is more family oriented and provides children and all people with good role models.
Music 2
Music & Movies Essay, Research Paper Music & Movies This paper is based on what I know about music. Music is a way of life, and life would be a mistake without music. Music can encourage ones emotions, thoughts, and feelings.
Purpose Essay Research Paper MusicIn Aaron Copland
Purpose Essay, Research Paper Music In Aaron Copland s essay How We Listen to Music, he examines the three ways people listen to music. He calls the ways we listen to music planes . The three planes he examines are the Sensuous Plane, Expressive Plane, and Sheerly Musical Plane (400). He uses examples of each plane and how people use it.
Data Mining
& Music Industry Essay, Research Paper Bruce Haring, in his article “Datamining: Spam or Future of Music Business” appearing in Inside states that “Bands are beginning to embrace the data-collection method…” and then poses the question, “…will some fans be put off by the tactic?” Disappointingly, he fails to answer the question of fan response to datamining (DM) in the article and instead gives many examples of why it is a huge element of the future of the music industry marketing, and at present is grossly underutilized.
AfroAmerican Dance Essay Research Paper Samuel A
Afro-American Dance Essay, Research Paper Samuel A. Floyd, Jr. stated in his essay that the development of Black music and Black dance in the United States each influenced the other in their mutually dependent evaluations. In Floyd’s essay he touch’s base with only some of the numerously wide variety of historical dancers, dances of the Afro-American culture, and music compositions that lead to the development of Black dance in the United States.
Chopin Essay Research Paper Chopin Chopin was
Chopin Essay, Research Paper Chopin Chopin was a Polish-born composer, one of the masters of piano composition. He wrote chamber music which is music for small groups of instruments, songs, and pieces for piano and orchestra. But his fame rests almost entirely on his more than 200 compositions for solo piano.He was born in Zelazowa-Wola, near Warsaw.He played the piano in public when he was only 8 years old.
Classical Music
’s Effects Essay, Research Paper Classical Music and its effects on the Neonate In Today s society music is very diverse. It produces feelings and emotions sensed by all walks of life. Different styles of music tend to give different ideas and impressions to people. It affects everyone it comes in contact with, and it is more powerful than we are willing to understand.
Popular Music Essay Research Paper Popular RadioThese
Popular Music Essay, Research Paper Popular Radio These days you get into your car, flip on the radio, and what do you hear? A barrage of fake music. Lets name just a few to familiarize you with what I am speaking of: Back Street Boys, N’ Sync, Brittany Spears, 98 Degrees, Christina Agulera, Jessica Simpson, the list goes on and on.
The Digital World Essay Research Paper Today
?The Digital World? Essay, Research Paper Today we live in ?the digital world?, the internet reins supreme it?s the future, the next frontier. The age of digital music is upon us mp3s ras wmas etc. and along with all this is a means to share it. File shareing services and software. It is now possible to go online type in the name of the song wanted and download it.