NAPSTER:
BREAKING THE CONSTITUTION
The Napster software, which launched in 1999, allows people to share digital music
files (MP3) between each other. This Internet program has sparked a historical debate about
copyright law and the Internet. Copyright owners strongly believe that “sharing” these files
via Napster is “stealing”(TIME).
Downloading music against the wishes of an artist or producer is breaking the law.
Some believe that it is not stealing or illegal. They are just making a copy of someone’s
song. In the Constitution, Article 1, Section 8 it says “……promote the Progress of Science
and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right
to their respective Writings and Discoveries…..” (Constitution). This led to copyright law,
which gives artists the exclusive rights to their music from the moment of its creation until,
generally 70 years after the artist dies (Michigan Review). There may not be respect for the
copyright law, but it is still breaking the law.
According to the Michigan Review, in areas around college campuses and
universities, CD sales have dropped 4%. In 2000, retail CD sales at stores near colleges with
high Napster use are actually below 1997 sales (Michigan Review). That is a huge reversal
in an area that usually sees high demand for music. Also according to the Michigan Review,
CD sales are up 16% across the nation. How can Napster be a bad thing if it is helping the
record industry? Maybe some people buy CDs based on what they hear on Napster, but for
most college students Napster has the opposite effect. Colleges and universities have been
hotbeds for sharing of online music files by a variety of methods for many years. All
Napster and similar tools have done is make this sharing of files much easier (Newsweek).
There are no in-betweens here. In all fairness to the artist, one should make a choice.
They should buy it or delete it from their computer. Some people might not like a song
well enough to want to pay for it so they feel like no one is losing a profit. If one does not
like a song well enough to buy it, they should not even be listening to it. However, consider
this scenario in defense of a Napster user. What if someone only wants one song on a $20.00
CD? Is it fair for the Artist to in essence be charging that person $20.00 for one song? In
this situation the consumer would not purchase the CD therefore the Artist would lose out
any profit. Action must be taken to benefit both the consumer, the Artist and our
Constitutional rights as Americans.
Some artist work for years to establish themselves as a popular musician, spending
untold fortunes on recording equipment, training, marketing, plus thousands of man-hours
on perfecting their craft, only to have their work ripped off by someone. What it all comes
down to is a persons own values. Most people have too few songs in their collection to
worry about being prosecuted. Penalties for copyright infringement are harsh—5 years in
jail, up to $250,000 in fines, and possible statutory damages of up to $150,000 per song
(TIME).
Since the music is “free” it has to be stealing. In America, one does not get anything
for free. People are robbing artists from the pennies they earn on each CD that sells. Many
people believe that it is the same thing as recording a song off the radio. But they came up
with a solution to that problem. Now, artists are compensated every time a song is played
on the radio (Newsweek).
The courts need to find a way to protect artists’ intellectual property rights in the
emerging e-commerce arena. The core of the lawsuit is more about the changes in
technology and new technology (TIME). There has to be a way to reconcile this technology
with artists’ rights. If an artist writes and sings a song and someone else benefits from it
without compensating the artists, the artist is hurt. President Bush comments on the Napster
case by saying, “A way must be found to apply our copyright laws to ensure that artists,
writers, and creators can earn a profit from their creations, while at the same time, adapting
to and utilizing new technologies to deliver media to consumers in an Information Age”
(TIME). According to Newsweek magazine, more than half of the people using Napster do
not feel guilty of violating the copyright law when they are downloading music off the
Internet. The people that use these functions on the net have a very different view of their
rights, and what they think is right, than those that are in the general Internet community.
This is not fair to the recording industry because they are not making any money from it.
Napster should at least charge people a set fee for using it. In return, they can pay the artists’
when someone downloads their music.
Today web users must pay to access certain services such as America On-Line
(AOL), Microsoft Internet Explorer and others. A monthly fee, sometimes based on per-
minute usage or a flat fee, compensates the company for their “copyrighted” material.
Napster, or other similar exchange sites, could charge a monthly fee, transactional fee, or
some combination of both to compensate the artist for their songs. This system would allow
for exchange of one or more songs without obligating a buyer to purchase a whole CD while
compensating the artist.
Americans have many rights granted to them by the United States Constitution.
Diversity, abortion and many other trivial issues relating to a persons individual rights have
been overcome. Copyright issues, although not as extreme as some issues, are very crucial
in this day and age (TIME). Lawmakers must uphold the writers of the constitutions ideas
yet apply them to today’s issues. The Constitution does not grant a right to steal and
expressly speaks to “Authors and Inventors Rights to their respective Writings and
Discoveries…”. It is now up to the lawmakers to allow the constitutional ideas to merge with
that of the new e-commerce business, respect the Constitution of the United States and
compensate those artist, songwriters, and others for their work.
Greenwald, John. “Who Needs Napster.” TIME . 23 October 2000: 22-25/
Sloan, Allan. “Playing Fair With Copyright” Newsweek. Feb. 2001 43-46/
U. S. CONST. art. 1 V ? 8
Schwartz, Scott M.. “The Great Napster Debate.” Michigan Review. October
11-25, 2000. *http
Другие работы по теме:
Napster Essay Research Paper The problems faced
Napster Essay, Research Paper The problems faced by Napster and how it affects us. INTRODUCTION Shawn Fanning let his closely cropped coiffure grow a bit shaggy, so his friends started calling him “nappy.” That evolved into a new nickname, “Napster,” which became the Internet handle he used in chat rooms.
Cyber Battle The People Versus Napstercom Essay
, Research Paper Napster is a music search engine founded by Shawn Fanning about a year ago. It is a software program that allows individuals to search for their favorite music selection by connecting to millions of other users around the world. Napster is basically the simplest way to find MP3?s that you want anytime and the same time be able to share the selections with the world?s largest community of music lovers.
Go Napster Essay Research Paper Shawn Fanning
Go Napster Essay, Research Paper Shawn Fanning, a freshman in college, launched Napster in the beginning of 1999.Napster allows Internet users to share and download MP3 (music) files directly from any computer connected to the Napster network, which could be hundreds of thousands of people.You can use Napster by downloading the software from the Internet site, and then connecting to the network using this software, which allows the sharing of all your MP3 files with anyone else on the network.Unlike many other file sharing networks, Napster limits their users to only download MP3 files.The advantage of these files are that they can be very close to CD quality and are one-tenth the size of a wave file.This is the main reason that many artists and record labels are concerned with the MP3 file format and programs like Napster that makes it very easy to share copyrighted material.The fact
Napster Controversy Essay Research Paper NapsterWhat is
Napster Controversy Essay, Research Paper Napster What is the big deal with the whole napster controversy? All it is is a network, which allows millions of people to share files, which are already available on the Internet.
Napster Essay Research Paper Ruling could doom
Napster Essay, Research Paper Ruling could doom Napster A federal court ruled yesterday that Napster must stop allowing users to swap copyrighted music. Napster officials said they would keep operating while they fought in court. Napster was created by a teenager in 1999. Napster’s software lets computer users trade audio files by connecting with one another.
Napster Essay Research Paper Napster is an
Napster Essay, Research Paper Napster is an integrated browser and communications system provided by Napster, Inc., to enable musicians and music fans to locate bands and music available in the MP3 and WMA music formats. The MP3 and WMA files that you locate using Napster are not stored on Napster’s servers.
Is Napster Illegal Essay Research Paper Is
Is Napster Illegal Essay, Research Paper Is Napster illegal? Tough question… Actually, the issue really isn’t whether Napster is legal or not. The corporate suits and rich-bitch musicians would argue so, but it’s just a cover for their fears. They’re basically afraid of Napster because its done something that hasn’t happened in a while, but so desperately needed to happen.
Napster Essay Research Paper NapsterWhat would you
Napster Essay, Research Paper Napster What would you do if had a access to all the music that you wanted and it was free? Well, in the age of the internet this situation is possible with mp3 s. Mp3 s are compressed digital audio files which has near cd quality sound. It was developed by a German engineering form called Fraunhofer IIS in 1987.
Napsters Problem Essay Research Paper The Problem
Napsters Problem Essay, Research Paper The Problem with Napster The sole reason behind anybody’s discrepency with Napster is because there is a group, maybe even the majority its users abuse what it is capable of.
XNapster Essay Research Paper XNapsterThe infamous Napster
X-Napster Essay, Research Paper X-Napster The infamous Napster under attack for it s pirating of music from famous musician s needs to be shut down. Piracy is a major issue of moral standards, right, and wrong in the entertainment world. Napster is well known for it s sharing of MP3 files through the Internet; taking, receiving, and bootlegging.
Legal Vs Illegal Essay Research Paper Legal
Legal Vs. Illegal Essay, Research Paper Legal vs. Illegal (Napster vs. Music Industry) The issues that will be slugged out in federal district court in San Francisco sound a little too pop culture to be all that serious. How many music CDs are people buying these days in record stores throughout the nation because of Napster? Is the technology that Napster uses legal? Napster is, of course, the wildly popular file-sharing service whose 20 million users have downloaded some half a billion songs–most copyrighted for free.
Dark As Hell Essay Research Paper The
Dark As Hell Essay, Research Paper The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) is suing Napster for allegedly enabling music piracy through its proprietary MusicShare program. MusicShare allows music lovers to open up their stores of MP3 files to all other Napster users. Whenever a user is online, his MP3s are up for grabs, with the only stipulation being that users upload a file for each one that they download.
Napster And Musician Rights Essay Research Paper
Music copyright is something that will always be in question. Many people believe that music is for all to hear and should not be restricted on how we obtain it. Napster is the greatest controversy in the United States at current. Many musicians and people believe others should have free access to all music.
The Federal Reserve System Essay Research Paper
Should Napster be prosecuted? Napster a free music sharing software is in the mist of being sued by many music corporation for copyright infringement. Napster users download and upload copyright music without the permission of the copyright owners which is illegal. People who write, perform, and produce the music don’t even recieve a royality from there work which is considered stealing.
Shutting Down Napster Is Not The
Solution Essay, Research Paper Shutting Down Napster is Not the Solution Almost everyone has heard of Napster and its long debated issue s of file swapping and sharing. Considering Napster s short-lived existence of about a year and a half, they have certainly opened many people s eyes. Some say the file swapping that Napster allows everyone to do is illegal; others says it s just another thing to do on the internet.
The Great Napster Essay Research Paper THE
The Great Napster Essay, Research Paper THE GREAT NAPSTER Napster is innovative file-sharing software that lets an online community of music lovers trade MP3 files free of charge. You search for a song by name, and a list of people who have it pops up and you can choose whomever you want to get it from, and in addition, you can see and download any other songs that they may have in their files.
Abortion Essay Research Paper wwwpottersschoolcomabortionIs it right
Abortion Essay, Research Paper www.pottersschool/abortion/ Is it right or is it wrong? Is it murder or is it a woman’s choice. There are so many conflicting views, but who is right? The debate over abortion will probably never be settled in my life time. As with many computer literate people, the author of this site gives us an objective view on abortion.
Rogerian Argument
– Pronapster Essay, Research Paper Simple Solution for Napster Lately, there has been a significant amount of concern regarding software programs that promote the sharing of songs at a minimal cost to the consumer. These networks allow users to swap computer files in the form of MP3s among one another via the World Wide Web.
Napster Vs Riaa Essay Research Paper Napster
Napster Vs Riaa Essay, Research Paper Napster vs. Music Industry Napster is an ongoing controversy on the Web. Napster is a software program that allows anyone to find their favorite music by connecting them to the computers of millions of other users. It is the simplest way to find the MP3s they want, whenever they want, and share them with the world’s largest community of music lovers.
The Mp3 Controversy Essay Research Paper A
The Mp3 Controversy Essay, Research Paper A major news item lately has been what is called The MP3 Controversy. It is based on the free trade of music files known as MP3s, which are small enough to be easily downloaded but have the same quality as a compact disc. Computer users are able to download these files from the internet and then burn them onto CDs that can be played in any regular CD player.
Napster Debate Essay Research Paper Napster DebateFor
Napster Debate Essay, Research Paper Napster Debate For a project in college eighteen-year old Shawn Fanning wrote a program for a way to download music off the internet. He later put the program on the internet and Napster was born. Napster is a program that allows you to download music on the internet. Since this program is free, many people have downloaded Napster.
Napster1 Essay Research Paper Napster The Napster
Napster1 Essay, Research Paper Napster The Napster Controversy In the controversy against Napster, many supporters fight to keep their freedom alive. This case is about whether the plaintiffs can use their control of music copyrights to achieve control over Napster’s decentralized technology and prevent it from transforming the Internet in ways that might undermine their present chokehold on music promotion and distribution.
RIAA Vs Napster Essay Research Paper The
RIAA Vs Napster Essay, Research Paper The debate over whether or not Napster Inc. is in violation of existing copyright infringement laws is a complex issue. Napster?s defense attorneys
Napster Essay Essay Research Paper Who wouldn
Napster Essay Essay, Research Paper Who wouldn t want to get free music off the Internet? I know I would jump at the chance to be able to get all the music I ve ever wanted for free. This is what the program Napster has attempted to do. But, you have to as yourself, what about copyright laws? What would happen if everybody stopped buying albums because they could get it for free? Napster has broken copyright laws, and album sales have decreased because of Napster.
Napster
’S Upshot Essay, Research Paper Napster’s Upshot Bickering, oh the endless bickering! It seems like that has become the pastime of the record industry and the estimated 32 million Napster users. All this frustration was brought about when Napster revolutionized the use of person-to-person file sharing over the net.
Napster Essay Research Paper The Napster RevolutionHave
Napster Essay, Research Paper The Napster Revolution Have you ever listened to your favorite song on the radio and recorded it? I remember when I would sit next to the radio and listen to it for hours at-a-time, just so that I could record my favorite songs off the radio. Now with computers and the Internet, I would go all over the Internet to look for songs, but only some of the time I was successful.
Napster Essay Research Paper There are many
Napster Essay, Research Paper There are many different controversies when consulting the topic on Napster. Napster is a computer program that lets people download mp3 music files from other people with the program. Lots of people and music companies believe that this is bad and Napster should be stopped or should charge people.
Napster Essay Research Paper Napster is continuing
Napster Essay, Research Paper Napster is continuing to comply with the District Court?s injunction and to prevent the record companies from shutting down file sharing. In the process of doing so, we have implemented a range of filters designed to remove from the Napster service all copyrighted works for which we have received notice.
Napster Essay Research Paper For many years
Napster Essay, Research Paper For many years the record companies have fixed record prices to avoid competing with each other and to maximize their profits. Currently, the record companies are collaborating in order to force Napster to shut down. The record companies are claiming that Napster is breaking copyright laws.
Mobile PhonesInternet Essay Research Paper MobileCell PhonesMobile
Mobile Phones/Internet Essay, Research Paper Mobile/Cell Phones Mobile phones have changed the way the world communicates. With the invention of the cellular phone service in 1983, personal telephones no longer depended on wires. In the 90’s it was now possible to connect to the Internet from virtually anywhere in the world from your cellular phone using satellite services.
The Napster Debate Essay Research Paper The
The Napster Debate Essay, Research Paper The Napster Debate The Napster software (napster), established in May of 1999, allows Internet users to share and download MP3 files directly from any computer connected to the Napster network. The software downloads a client program from the Napster site and then connects to the network through the software.
Napster Essay Research Paper Napster By Alexis
Napster Essay, Research Paper Napster By: Alexis Alexis Frank IST 333 August 9,2000 Napster In less than one year Napster has become the hot application that has some 20 million users running to their computer. Napster is currently fighting for its life against a court ordered shutdown, but it seems that people will find a way to share and downloud on line music no matter what.
Napster Company Meltdown Essay Research Paper Napster
Napster: Company Meltdown Essay, Research Paper Napster: Company Meltdown? A nineteen-year-old entrepreneur, named Shawn Fanning, created Napster in 1999 as an elaborate plan to download music better from the Internet. Since its creation, Napster has caught on in the cyber world like wildfire. Ask any college student if he or she has heard of this company and you will hear a resounding YES! .