Paper
Morbid Fascinations:
Carroll on Horror
The Philosophy of Horror; or Paradoxes of the Heart by Noel Carroll is an in depth look at the reasons why so many people are intrinsically drawn to images of horror and gore and death in film, art, and life. Carroll discuss the many avenues that people have taken in the past to explain this phenomenon,
this apparent paradox of how “artistic presentation of normally averse events and objects can give rise to pleasure.”(Carroll, p 161) This paradox is a particularly interesting subject with a multitude of explanations and ruminations with only a few
actually encompassing the full range of the genre. Horror has an immense following in literature, film, and all other forms of art. Carroll attempts to explain the fascination with art-horror and the implications of the greater social functions that the experience of horror in film and other media perform.
Carroll asks the problematic question “Why Horror?” why is this genre of categorically repulsive material so compelling to its viewers? There are many theories as to why, but most fall short and no not encompass the true nature and breadth of the genre. One arguments put forth by H.P. Lovecraft is the idea of ‘Cosmic Awe’. This idea, this attempt to explain away our enjoyment of the grotesque and horrific, is based on the assumption that “humans are born with a kind of fear of the unknown which verges on awe”(p 162). Fear is ordinarily an unpleasant feeling and not one that one would want to reproduce on purpose artificially; however fear combined with awe of the
sublime is something all together different and could be pleasurable. Horror inspires wonder and keeps alive “the instinctual feeling of awe about the unknown”(p 162). Carroll is not satisfied with that explanation because it does not include all works of the genre and therefore can not be a defining quality much less and answer to the paradox. Many films fall short of arousing Cosmic Awe, yet they are still
compelling.
Carroll also dismisses the theory of Horror as a religious
experience. Some films may inspire religious awe with god-like
seductive powers of their monsters, but like the Cosmic Awe
theory it is not true of all. These do play a part in defining
the enjoyment of some elements of the horror genre.
The psychoanalytical reasons for the paradox are more
broad in their scope. Horror has interwoven within its
structure many of the myths and images that are used for
interpretation in psychoanalysis so it is understandable that
horror can be read by these myths. Freudian analysis is
particularly useful in looking at the symbolic elements in
horror that may draw its audience to it. Wish Fulfillment is
one area that is looked at. According to Carroll Horror films
like nightmares are simultaneously attractive and repellent
because they harbor both the wish and its inhibition. “The
paradox of Horror can be explained…by saying that the
ambivalence felt toward the objects of horror derives from a
deeper ambivalence about our most enduring psychosexual
desires”(p 170). Carroll expands that narrow definition by also
including repressed anxieties. Psychoanalysis is an avenue that
has its possibilities but not all monsters are repressed
anxieties or sexual desires.
Finally what Carroll’s proposes is a new theory of his own
that suggests that :
For What is attractive–what holds our interest
and yields pleasure–in the horror genre need
not be, first and foremost, the simple
manifestation of the object of art-horror,
but the way that manifestation or disclosure
is situated as a functional element in an overall
narrative structure(p 179)
It is in the whole narrative that the fascination is
derived from rather then just the grotesque or a particular part
of the piece. It is the interest in the outcome of the
questions that were raised by the film. Carroll’s theory
applies to all categories and sub-categories of art-horror. The
other methods of reasoning have a place in the discussions of
the attractions to horror but only in specifics and not to the
genre as a whole.
Carroll’s point is a simple one yet it does elucidate the
paradox. “Horror attracts because anomalies command attention
and elicit curiosity”(p 195). This is true in life as well.
There is a profound morbid fascination that takes over people as
they pass by accidents on the highway, tune into details about
vicious murders, and stare at those afflicted with anomalies.
There is this urge to observe death and decay from a safe
distance. There is an innate desire to “Observe a horror and be
social with it if they would let [you]” as said by Ishmael in
Moby Dick.
Horror can also be seen to have an ideology and serve as a
part of the function of society. They can be seen to serve the
purpose of the fairy-tail to warn young people about the dangers
out there. This is illustrated by the “fool around and you’ll
get what you can expectdeserve”(p 196) clich? in horror movies.
The Films can be looked at as anti-establishment as well as
upholding the status-quo. “Works of horror represent
transgressions of the standing conceptual categories of the
culture”(p 210). It depends on the film and the interpretation
as to what the political end may be.
Carroll’s views can be enlightening when applied to
horrors movies. Clive Barker’s Hellraiser for example is easily
interpretable in the direction of Carroll’s views. There is
ambivalence whether demonic creature “Pin head” serves as a
inspiration towards Cosmic Awe, a religios experience, or even
as a suppressed pyschosexual desire and anxiety. The character
and what he represents seems to encompass all of those and only
Carroll’s category seems to fit.
This movie is particularly grotesque and there is much
carnage and gory reshaping of the human body. Carroll’s idea
that it is curiosity and a urge to witness the end of the over
all narrative applies well to this. Good does not triumph and
the monster is not subdued, and this plays into Carroll’s theory
that the ideology of film can not be simply defined one way; the
normal-abnormal-normal formula is not always present. There is,
however, another idea that was not raised by Carroll. Horror
films such as Hellraiser can be used as a tool that
paradoxically quiets our fears as it simultaneously excites
them. The viewer remaining unscathed can witness the
destruction of human flesh and render it unreal because it is in
fact ‘only a movie’. Our fears about of own mortality and
corporeality is lessened by the excursion into destruction. The
body being manipulated and taken apart on screen is an outlet
for our fears and a means to gain power over them. By watching
our greatest fears we can gain control over them and put them in
perspective. This morbid fascination is in effect a catharsis.
Carroll’s views on horror give great insight into the
genre and the multitude of past theories. The public’s
fascination with the macabre and art-horror in particular is a
fascinating yet completely understandable phenomenon. “Why
horror?”– As long as there is depravity, fear, and death, there
will be the a line outside the movie theater buying tickets to
the new slasher flick.
352
Другие работы по теме:
Oedipus Sophecle
’s Tragic Her Essay, Research Paper Oedipus: Sophecles Tragic Hero A perfect tragedy should imitate actions which excite pity and fear and through pity and fear effect the proper purgation of the emotions. (Aristotle, Poetics) Oedipus Rex, by Sophecles, is a true tragedy and the character of Oedipus is the archetype of the tragic hero.
All Quiet On The Western Front -
– Human Experience Essay, Research Paper War is, at the same time, the most terrible and the greatest of human experiences. Is this the view conveyed in All quiet on the western front?
Stephan King Essay Research Paper Stephen King
Stephan King Essay, Research Paper Stephen King was born on September 21, 1947 in Portland, Maine. In 1949, when Stephen was 2 years old, his father left one night and never came back. There are a couple of turning points in his young life that he believes pointed him in the direction that he now is at. In 1954 he began to write stories.
Dose Poetry Matter Essay Research Paper Does
Dose Poetry Matter Essay, Research Paper Does Poetry Matter? To me poetry does not matter. I do not like poetry because a poem is just a passage that contains a hidden meaning and I can never figure out what a poem is about. If poetry was not around then authors would just come out and say what they wanted to say . Their thoughts would not get confused and people would not miss the meaning that the author is trying to get across.
Dracula Essay Research Paper The creation of
Dracula Essay, Research Paper The creation of this monster was actually based upon a Romanian myth,(derived from the word draclu-devil) which implied the existence of vampires or the undead, as Stoker says. But, let?s look at this novel in a different way. Who was Dracula?
Scream 3 Essay Research Paper Scream is
Scream 3 Essay, Research Paper Scream is a movie created by Wes Craven (creator of A Nightmare on Elm Street) is a turn of the tables on the typical horror flick. The problem with today s slasher movies is that the character s are all one-note stereotypes, the plots are ridiculous, the action always follows the same dreary pattern, and the only creative effort is in the new bloody makeup effects.
Genres Of Movies Essay Research Paper Tim
Genres Of Movies Essay, Research Paper Tim Robison English 1101.03 Myers March 30, 1999 Outline Topic: What types of movies do you prefer? Discuss these categories and explain your preferences.
Charles Lutwidge Dodgson
– Lewis Carroll Essay, Research Paper English 265 – Modern Poetry Poet: Lewis Carroll Term Paper Charles Lutwidge Dodgson was born on the 27th of January in the year of 1832 and died on the 14th of that same month in 1898. His pseudonym, Lewis Carroll, was born on March 1st, 1856 and was destined to live forever.
Louis Carroll Essay Research Paper The writings
Louis Carroll Essay, Research Paper The writings of Louis Carroll have been described as “inspired wordplay set within the frame of an idiosyncratic view of the humansituation.” Does this really sound right? If, not here is another lookat this enigmatic storyteller: “Carroll s art is so well concealed, hisprose so limpid that we may fail to realize how carefully the stories areorganized.
Stephen KingS Why We Crave Horror Movies
? Essay, Research Paper A Critique of Stephen King?s ?Why We Crave Horror Movies? Elliot Potter In Stephen King?s essay ?Why We Crave Horror Movies? he suggested that
Rasomon Essay Research Paper The HorrorA horror
Rasomon Essay, Research Paper The Horror A horror more terrible then fires – wars – epidemics – or bandits, this overwhelming horror is the weak character of man, the distrust and selfishness feeding each characters continual suspicion of his fellow man, always expecting the worst of them. The priest describes this horrific human trait and the world it creates with but a few lines;
Nightmarish Themes In Edgar Allan Poe
’s Stories Essay, Research Paper Themes in Works by Edgar Allan Poe Horror stories seem to provoke a certain feeling inside all of us. They can make us scared, nervous, or even just amazed. If a horror story is told well, it can make just about any reader cringe. There are certain elements that must be in a horror story to really make it frightening.
Frankenstein By Mary Shelley 1797
– 1851) Essay, Research Paper Mary Shelley wrote this novel on a dare at the age of nineteen. While she and her husband (the renowned poet Percy Bysshe Shelley) were vacationing with Lord Byron and others in the Alps
The Futility Of Dying For A State
Through Poetic Devices: Essay, Research Paper The Futility of Dying for a State through Poetic Devices: “Dulce et Decorum Est” and “The Death of the Ball Turret Gunner”
Why Do People Like Scarry Movies Essay
, Research Paper For years people have been scared by horror movies and they continue going back. Alfred Hitchcock once said, “drama is life with the dull bits left out.” Why do people like to watch other people get hurt and die while being scared enough to make them jerk in their seat? Movie goers like horror movies because people in general have dull lives.
Faust Essay Research Paper By Nick CarrollLet
Faust Essay, Research Paper By Nick Carroll Let my work benefit all!! Pryor High School Students: If you plagiarize this, you will most likely get caught, so I don’t advise doing so. Have Fun!!
Annabel Lee Essay Research Paper Edgar Allen
Annabel Lee Essay, Research Paper Edgar Allen Poe s “Annabel Lee” is a tale of mourning and lost love. Written beautifully and eloquently one can almost forget what the poem is actually saying. “Annabel Lee” is, at best, dark and depressing. But the first time it is read, and the second time, and the third time, for a few people, it is still proclaimed to be “pretty”.
Stephen King Essay Research Paper Stephen King
Stephen King Essay, Research Paper Stephen King Stephen King is a well-known and talented horror/fiction author who has published over eleven books in the last two decades. His great stories of
Purple Loosestrife Essay Research Paper subject
Purple Loosestrife Essay, Research Paper subject = Biology title = Purple Loosestrife papers = Lvl1 Biology 9/12/96 Purple Loosestrife Lythrum Salicaria L. or Purple Loosestrife is a plant causing much trouble today. It
Horror Is Enthralling Essay Research Paper Horror
Horror Is Enthralling Essay, Research Paper Horror is enthralling Meeting with fear-causing sensations is a thing that most of us consider as fun entertainment. Facing states of horror frightens, but at the same time interests us. What matter behind horror actually gives one such satisfaction?
The Horror The Horror Essay Research Paper
“The horror! The horror!” What exactly does mr. Kurtz refer to when he shouts these few words the moment before he dies? In considering this questio, we must understand his psychological state, which in turn is determined by what he underwent in the uncivilized world of the Belgian Congo. However, there is no direct account of his journey in Heart of Darkness.
Alice Essay Research Paper In Lewis Carroll
Alice Essay, Research Paper In Lewis Carroll’s novel Alice in Wonderland, Alice is curious, well-mannered, and confused while she tries to find her way out of Wonderland. Alice meets many unique and weird creatures which eventually help her escape wonderland. Alice shows that she is curious through her actions.
Alice In Wonderland Interpretations Essay Research Paper
Alice in Wonderland – Critical Review Philosophy – a subject that had driven people insane for as long as humans know their history. All the time people try to find a meaning, and later controvert it. For example, critics view a novel by Lewis Carroll Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, as a quest for maturity story, Carroll’s view on Victorian Society and even existential meaning on life.
Differences Between Alice
’s Adventures In Wonderland And Through The Looking Glass Essay, Research Paper At the mention of the name Alice, one tends to usually think of the children?s stories by Lewis Carroll. Namely, Alice?s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass are two classic works of children?s literature that for over a century have been read by children and adults alike.
Horror Movies Essay Research Paper Natural Born
Horror Movies Essay, Research Paper ?Natural Born Killers,? ? Psycho,? ? Friday the 13th ,? and ?The Legend of Sleepy Hollow? are all horror films. In these films there is always some crazy person or monster-like character that goes around and slaughters innocent people. And usually, but not all the time the killer is killed at the end of the movie.
Movies Essay Research Paper Many people go
Movies Essay, Research Paper Many people go to the movies. The movies are an escape into a fantasy world. Everyone has a different preference on what kind of movie is the best. Romance, horror, action, and comedy are different types of movies. The kind of movie someone goes to see can give clues to what kind of person they are.
Poem Objects Essay Research Paper Max E
Poem: Objects Essay, Research Paper Max E. Gaytan 4-5-00 One object can unlock All secrets of the world. It can create happiness And endless piece in the World. It can cure diseases
Carrol And Influences Of Alice In Wonderland
Essay, Research Paper Events or people in their lives inspire many authors. It is reflected in their writing. Lewis Carroll was inspired to write Alice in Wonderland by the real-life relationship with an Alice and his other child-friends.
Alice In Wonderland Essay Research Paper Alice
Alice In Wonderland Essay, Research Paper Alice in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll, a story about a little girl and her adventures in a dream-like place called wonderland, has been a beloved children’s story for over one hundred years. Though viewed by many as a simple children’s tale, if it is taken into a little more depth one will find that is a brilliant satire on the English system of government.
Alice In Wonderland Essay Research Paper As
Alice In Wonderland Essay, Research Paper As we read Alice?s Adventures in Wonderland and The Island of Dr. Moreau, we enter into two unique worlds of imagination. Both Lewis Carroll and H.G. Wells describe lands of intrigue and mystery. We follow Alice and Prendick into two different worlds where animals speak, evolution is tested, and reality is bent until it nearly breaks.
Alice Essay Research Paper As we read
Alice Essay, Research Paper As we read Alice?s Adventures in Wonderland and The Island of Dr. Moreau, we enter into two unique worlds of imagination. Both Lewis Carroll and H.G. Wells describe lands of intrigue and mystery. We follow Alice and Pren*censored* into two different worlds where animals speak, evolution is tested, and reality is bent until it nearly breaks.