Arnold Toynbee Excerpt Essay, Research Paper
In “Menschheit und Mutter Erde”, the author, Arnold Toynbee, describes his point of view concerning man’s relationship and interaction with the earth’s biosphere and also gives an insight on a future development of both.
Tonybee begins with a clear definition of the term biosphere. The biosphere is defined as being the layer of the earth’s crust, water and air, which surrounds our planet. After this definition, he points out that our biosphere is very small compared to the diameter of the earth or other dimensions in our solar system or the universe. Up to now, it is the only habitable place for humans in this solar system, but over the past centuries man has played the most important role in the pollution and destruction of it. Therefore the search for other suitable biospheres in our solar system or in other solar systems has become of an increasing importance, but by today’s scientific knowledge, it seems like this is the only biosphere in this solar system. Assuming that there are other habitable biospheres in the nearby solar systems or even in this one, the planets are too far away to be reached within the lifespan of a human being. And it is practically impossible to provide a ship with enough food for several generations in order to reach these planets. Therefore our possibilities to solve this problem are limited to this biosphere.
Mankind has the ability to destroy our biosphere and will inevitably do so within a certain period of time if the exploitation does not stop. But man cannot stop the natural process of decay that is due to the fact that the biosphere is not autarkic. The biosphere’s source of energy, the sun, is known to change and will eventually vanish some day as well. Therefore man has no influence on the natural process itself.
Toynbee then summarizes the three elements of the biosphere and their relationship to each other. The biosphere consists of matter that did not come to life by adopting any organic structures, living organic matter, and non-living matter that had once been alive and organic and still contains organic characteristics. The biosphere is younger than the planet itself, and life and consciousness in the biosphere can never exist as long as the matter with which it had been combined. Former organic parts make up the biggest group of all three of the above, and is know to having provided man with some of the most important means for the maintenance of life. The fact that such a large amount of the earth’s matter had in fact been organic at some point, leads Toynbee to the aspects of evolution. The diversity and variety of species and individuals had been essential for the development of life. The natural selection is therefore the natural result of this development. And in many cases the extinction of one species had been the result of an indirect fight for survival, because one species did not simply extinct another by feeding on it, but by taking up most of the essential sources of nourishment. It is also a given fact that a fight for water, food or a female between members of one species usually ends with the loser begging for mercy and the winner granting it as a response to the capitulation.
Human beings are the only life-forms who fight each other to death. Thus, the development of life was at best parasitic and at worst predator-like. Over the time, man became man’s own prey, which sometimes developed into extreme forms, such as slavery and cannibalism. Even though murder is being prosecuted in every country today, most sovereign countries have fought, or still fight, against each other in war. They expect their soldiers to kill the enemy soldiers and to risk being killed themselves. Even today, this sacrifice, the death for one’s country, is considered to be an honourable thing. Here Toynbee asks the question whether the progress of life justifies the pain and suffering, and if man can be considered to be worthier than a tree, and a tree worthier than an amoeba.
Even though man is the most powerful species of all, it still cannot survive on its own. Only man can be cruel and evil because he is the only one who is aware of his acts. The plant-animal relationship, for example, could be considered to be simply parasitic, because animals feed on plants without nourishing them in any way. But on the other hand, it can be called mutual because plants and animals work together for the same goal, that is to maintain the biosphere habitable for both of them. Therefore the progress and development have brought up both good and bad aspects. But this is an entirely human point of view. This might imply that man’s ethical and moral standards are entirely human and therefore arbitrary and that they are irrelevant for the reality of life. But since man is not simply a spectator, but is aware of his surroundings and able to make ethical decisions, he is a part of the tree of life, and therefore his decisions and standards are a part of the biosphere itself and the total reality, which the biosphere is a part of.
Toynbee here concludes that life and consciousness and good and evil are not less real than the matter with which they are combined in the biosphere.
But in the development of life consciousness did not appear until man appeared, and it took us until just recently to realize that the presence of man is an endangerment for the habitability of the biosphere. Despite this fact, the extinction of certain species and individuals does not seem to endanger the continuity of life itself. It is rather given that these extinctions make room for other species afterwards.
During the first and longest period of his history, man has left less significant traces than some of his contemporaries. Compared to the works of some microscopic life-forms, which, for example, built the coral reefs, man’s works seem small and irrelevant.
During the Christian era, people have realized that our biosphere is a limited hull, but still today, mankind seems to pretend that our biosphere supplies an unlimited amount of non-renewable resources. But obviously, there used to be some truth to this, because at the beginning of last century, it seemed impossible that man could ever have the power to destroy all this. But towards the third quarter of the century, the rapidly growing scientific sector, made it more and more likely to have an enormous influence on the biosphere. Man became the first life-form to gain such an extreme form of power that it could destroy our biosphere within a short period of time. Man is the fist life-form to be more powerful than the biosphere itself. But he cannot escape his Nemesis because the biosphere’s destruction instantly leads to his own extinction.
Toynbee now mentions earth’s first encounter with man. Since man is the only inhabitant who belongs to the spiritual world as well, he is a psychosomatic being who is involved in the material and finite world. His final goal is to rule over the non-human world, but in the spiritual world it is to rule over himself. Toynbee here suggests that these contrary goals have been mentioned in many famous texts, such as the Bible and the works of the Tao-te-king. In the last one it says that man’s technical achievements are a trap at the same time. According to Sir Thomas Brown, man is like an amphibian, he belongs to two different worlds, the biosphere as well as the spiritual world, and he strives for a distinct goal in each of the two worlds, but can never reach both of them; he has to choose.
But unfortunately, man mostly chooses the material path, the one that promises wealth and success. Toynbee here concludes that man can obviously not escape his own Nemesis unless he changes his attitude fundamentally.
Другие работы по теме:
The Hidden Identity Of Arnold Friend Essay
, Research Paper The Hidden Identity of Arnold Friend The world is full of people who portray themselves as someone or something else. People usually hide their identity to obtain things that they want. It is common to be fooled by someone’s
Ecclesiates 318 Essay Research Paper Interpretation of
Ecclesiates 3:1-8 Essay, Research Paper Interpretation of Ecclesiastes 3:1-8 The Bible verses Ecclesiastes 3:1-8 are Solomon?s words as he is telling of the relationship that we may have with God and of His master plan. We are to understand God?s impeccable timing, absolute control, magnificent grace, and eternal glory.
Stone Boy Essay Research Paper Creative Task
Stone Boy Essay, Research Paper Creative Task: The Stone Boy Six years ago, Arnold Curwing accidentally shot his brother with a .22 caliber rifle. He was nine years old at the time. Surrounding this incident, as you would expect, he was under fire by his neighbors and peers from thereon, even though it was an accident.
The Bluest Eyes Essay Research Paper 2
The Bluest Eyes Essay, Research Paper “The Bluest Eyes” Toni Morrison was an African American woman that had gone through almost forty years of suppression. In an excerpt from her novel The Bluest Eyes, she tells the story of a young girl named Claudia who receives a white baby doll every Christmas. Claudia does not like the doll so she decided to tear it apart like every other “white baby doll” that she has received.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Ticonderoga and Crown
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Ticonderoga and Crown point The immediate object of the attack on the British Forts at Ticonderoga and Crown Point on May 10 and 11, 1775 was first to capture the forts themselves, but also to obtain a cannon and supplies to use for the impending seige of Boston. Washington, who assumed command of the American forces on July 2, 1775, could not attempt this attack without heavy artillery, which was procured by Colonel Ethan Allen, Colonel Benedict Arnold and Colonel Seth Warner with Vermont?s Green Mountain Boys.
Oates
’ “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?”: Arnold Fiend Essay, Research Paper Oates’ “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?”: Arnold Fiend In Joyce Carol Oates’ ?Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been??
CommentaryJane EyreRedRoom Essay Research Paper Commentary on
Commentary-Jane Eyre(Red-Room) Essay, Research Paper Commentary on Jane Eyre This particular excerpt of Charlotte Br nte s Jane Eyre is in prose, told in a first person narrative. It is about the last moments that Jane Eyre is locked in the red room after being wrongly accused of pouncing on Mrs. Reed s son, in which her mind has drifted off to the topic of ghosts and spirits coming back from the dead to take revenge on the living and then, upon thinking she has seen a ghost, flies into a panic, waking the whole household and being severely scolded.
Friend Or Fiend Essay Research Paper Karen
Friend Or Fiend Essay, Research Paper Karen Mott Eng 201 Mr. Bloodworth 24 Sept., 1999 Friend or Fiend? The persona of a psychopath appears to be much like any human. In many cases, one would not be able to “pick them out of a crowd”. Their minds, however, differ greatly from most. A psychopath is extremely smart and methodical in thinking and most often is very meticulous in the way in which he/she acts.
Joyce Carol Oates Essay Research Paper 1
Joyce Carol Oates Essay, Research Paper English 101 ?Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been? In Joyce Carol Oates? ?Where Are you Going, Where Have You Been?, there is a clear interpretation of evil in Arnold Friend and how he as a demon tries to pull Connie into the dark world of sex and emotion. Oates seems to extract scenarios of real life and add them into her story.
Joyce Carol Oates Analysis Of His Short
Story Essay, Research Paper ?Did Connie Bring Arnold?s Actions Upon Herself? ?Her heart was almost too big for her chest and its pumping made sweat break out
BakerS Childhood Essay Research Paper The excerpt
Baker?S Childhood Essay, Research Paper The excerpt explains Baker?s childhood growing up in the 1930s. He lived in Belleville, NJ with his younger sister Doris, and his single mother. This story to talks about Russell growing up and how his mother pushed him to work and be responsible as a young adult, but all he wanted to do is listen to ?Dick Tracy meets the Stooge Viller? on the radio reading his book.
Dover Beach Essay Research Paper How can
Dover Beach Essay, Research Paper How can life or anything be so wonderful, but at times seem so unbearable? This is a question that Matthew Arnold may have asked himself one day, while writing
Dombey And Son Essay Research Paper In
Dombey And Son Essay, Research Paper In an excerpt from Dombey and Son by Charles Dickens, a man’s wife just gave birth to their newborn child and he’s already planning out the future of his son. Through a god-like view, the reader sees the arrogance of Dombey and feels pity towards his wife and son. Using rhetorical devices, Dickens tells of this man and his thoughts.
Where You Going Where Have You Been
? Essay, Research Paper The Devil?s Favorite Sin: Vanity In ?Where are You Going, Where Have you Been?? Joyce Carol Oates uses an allegorical figure of evil to illustrate the theme of temptation. Oates alludes to hell through the character Arnold Friend, as the devil, and his victim Connie, who invites him in by committing one of the devil?s favorites sins: vanity.
Stephen Douglas Essay Research Paper American Studies
Stephen Douglas Essay, Research Paper American Studies Assignment-Stephen A. Douglas My name is Stephen A. (Arnold) Douglas (born: April 23,1813- died: June3, 1861). I have been given the nickname “The Little Giant” representing my fiery conviction, prowess, and self-reliance. I believe that the country’s destined direction lies west.
Refutation Of A Literary Review On
“Joyce Carol Oate’s Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?” Essay, Research Paper Refutation Marie Mitchell Olesen Urbanski reflects on the parallels between a literary work and biblical suggestions in her essay ?Existential Allegory: Joyce Carol Oates ?Where Are You Going? Where Have You Been?? (Studies in Short Fiction, 1978.) In her criticism, she compares the story of Connie?s passive submission to Arnold Friend with the seduction of Eve by the Devil in the biblical myth.
Analysis Of Voice In Joyce Carol Oate
’s Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been Essay, Research Paper Language of Terror When a person is put in an incredibly horrifying situation where the outcome is unpredictable many physical and emotional changes take place. Joyce Carol Oates s story Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been? places Connie, a typical teenager, in this situation.
The Devil In Disguise Essay Research Paper
The Devil’s Advocate Is Arnold Friend the Devil in disguise in Joyce Carol Oates’ short story “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?” If one were to look at the facts surrounding the actual event this story was based on, any assumption that “Friend” was anything but a man would be thrown out due to logic. However, if one were to look at the story alone, he could concede that Friend is indeed the Devil or at least the Devil’s angel.
Dover Beach Essay Research Paper Dover Beachby
Dover Beach Essay, Research Paper ?Dover Beach? by: Matthew Arnold In the poem ?Dover Beach? by: Matthew Arnold there is a lot of irony, appeal to the auditory and visual sense, and illusions. The tone in this poem is very sad and dismal, but he shows us how to keep faith and hope in spite of that and how important being honest, true, and faithful to one another, really is.
Arnold Essay Research Paper What changes a
Arnold Essay, Research Paper What changes a military hero from a great patriot to a treasonous traitor? Benedict Arnold is the only man in our history to be a military hero for both sides. He is known to most in our country as a traitor but without his valiant efforts in battle against the British forces our country may not be singing the National Anthem but God Save the Queen.
Alice Essay Research Paper In Lewis Carroll
Alice Essay, Research Paper In Lewis Carroll’s novel Alice in Wonderland, Alice is curious, well-mannered, and confused while she tries to find her way out of Wonderland. Alice meets many unique and weird creatures which eventually help her escape wonderland. Alice shows that she is curious through her actions.
Comments On Matthew Arnold S Philistinism
In England And America (A Plato Critique) Essay, Research Paper Comments on Matthew Arnold s Philistinism in England and America In his essay, Philistinism in England and America, Matthew Arnold examines the ancient ideas of Plato in the context of a twentieth century, capitalist society. As he agrees with almost all of what Plato had to say, he also admits that he is outdated, and that some of his teachings cannot be applied to us, living in an industrial superpower such as the United States.
Matthew Arnold Essay Research Paper Matthew Arnolds
Matthew Arnold Essay, Research Paper Matthew Arnolds melancholy in life, religion, and love In Dover Beach, Matthew Arnold discusses his religious views, the melancholy in his life, and a new love, which he experiences by an isolated individual as he confronts the turbulent historical forces and the loss of religious faith in the modern world.
Comparison Of Karl Marx And Matthew Arnold
Essay, Research Paper Comparison of Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold Through their writing, Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold show their opposing views on the importance of internal and external functions of culture. In the
John Keats Romantism Essay Research Paper Identify
John Keat`s Romantism Essay, Research Paper Identify and discuss the elements of Romanticism as given expression in John Keats’ poem Lamia and William Wordsworth’s excerpt from The Excursion. The term
Jurassic Park Essay Research Paper Jurassic Park
Jurassic Park Essay, Research Paper Jurassic Park is a book about the cloning of dinosaurs and they are used as the park entertainment on an island. In this park where dinosaurs are the attraction, not every thing will go as planed. Reading this book will teach someone how Michael Crichton feels about biological science and the cloning of extinct animals.
Dover Beach Vs Dover Bitch Essay Research
Paper Hecht’s parody “Dover Bitch” is a mockery of Victorian values shown in “Dover Beach”, as well as those of his own period. Hecht candidly exaggerates the speech, ideas and symbols in “Dover Beach.”.
Benedict Arnold Essay Research Paper Arnold was
Benedict Arnold Essay, Research Paper Arnold was born on January 14, 1741, in Norwich, Connecticut. Both his parents were of long-established, well-respected New England families. He was helper to a pharmacist when he was a young. However, he liked the battlefield to a druggist’s life and enlisted in the militia during the French and Indian War (1754-1763).
Benedict Arnold Essay Research Paper SS 9
Benedict Arnold Essay, Research Paper S.S 9 L.G 10 Benedict Arnold Benedict Arnold was one of the important figures in the American Revolution. He began as a patriot, and soon later married a loyalist. Benedict
Benedict Arnold Essay Research Paper Benedict Arnold
Benedict Arnold Essay, Research Paper Benedict Arnold ARNOLD, Benedict (1741-1801). The name Benedict Arnold has become a synonym for a traitor to one’s country. In the first years of the American Revolution, however, Arnold was a brilliant and dashing general, highly respected for his service to the patriot cause (see Revolution, American).
Arnold Lazarus Essay Research Paper Arnold Lazarus
Arnold Lazarus Essay, Research Paper Arnold Lazarus was born in 1932. He was born and educated in Johannesburg, South Africa. “Although Dr. Lazarus grew up in South Africa, he strongly identified with the United States.” (Corey, 2001, chap. 10)