Should Know Essay, Research Paper
THE SONG OF ROLAND: SOME THINGS YOU SHOULD KNOW
Charles the Great invaded Spain in the year 778. He had been invited in by the governor of the strategic city of Zaragoza, who had promised to turn the city over to him. He entered through a pass in the western Pyrenees Mountains and marched through the lands of the Basques, a people who had managed to maintain their freedom from Muslim domination and who were not too pleased with the Franks entering their land without even asking permission. Charles took care of their objections by seizing hostages and allowing his men to loot and plunder the countryside as the headed east to Zaragoza. When he reached his objective, however, he found that the Muslim governor had changed his mind, and that the gates of the city were closed to him. After lingering a while to no purpose, he and his army began to retrace their steps. The Basques were still angry with his earlier treatment of them and, as his army went through the pass of Roncevalles, attacked his rearguard. As Einhard noted in his Life of Charlemagne, a few nobles were killed, including “Hrudoland, lord of the Marches of Brittany.”
By the 900’s, the shrine of Saint James of Compostela, located in the northeastern corner of Spain, had become one of the most popular pilgrimage sites of western Europe, and the main route from France to Saint James lay through the pass of Roncevalles. Over time, Roland became one of the heroes whose battlefield passing pilgrims were eager to see, and, eventually, he became the protagonist of an epic poem. Although historians have argued about when the written version that has survived was composed, most now agree that it dates from sometime about 1100, and was written somewhere in northern France. It is the most famous of a number of similar tales, more or less based upon the events of the era of the Carolingian monarchs and called chansons de geste. This means “songs of deeds,” and these songs were the preferred “literature” of the nobility of the twelfth century. They were sung to their audience, much as Beowulf was composed to be sung to an audience the members of which were most illiterate.
The idea that Roland and the other chansons were songs of deeds lead many readers to miss the complexity of these poems. If one views them simply as heroic tales in which one warrior chops up a bunch of other warriors, they can seem rather primitive and quickly become boring. The fact of the matter is that many of the chansons are actually concerned with legal points, and more than a few, like The Song of Roland, have an actual trial as their central episode. You will see this again when you read The Song of the Cid. They are much more like television programs such as Law and Order or Perry Mason than All-Star Wrestling or reruns of Rocky.
This is not to say that the smash and stab parts of these poems are not important. The audience probably loved them, but they realized that they were incidental to the main action, much as the chase scenes in which all sorts of cars smash into each other and blow up, scattering debris over half the city, provide excitement but are not really essential to the plot. Perhaps this is overstating the case. One tends to find out a good deal about the characters of the actors in the drama during these episodes. But it is best to concentrate your attention on the events leading up to the battle-scenes than on the blood and glory sections themselves. Another thing to remember is that medieval authors were not “primitive” or “unsophisticated.” They did expect their audience to pay close attention to what they were relating and to think about what they were hearing and reading. They also expected them to be familiar with the situations being pictured for them.
It was the duty of every feudal vassal, for instance, to “pay court” to his lord. That meant that the vassal was supposed to present himself on those occasions when the lord called for an assembly to consider problems, to hear complaints and settle disputes, to receive embassies, or anything else requiring serious thought and discussion. Most of the audience of The Song of Roland had experience in such meetings or was at least learning how one should behave when their lord asked them for “aid and counsel.” So it should not come as a surprise to see that Roland begins by providing the background necessary to understand why Charlemagne had called a council of his nobles and what issue the members of the council were suppose to discuss and offer advice about. You might keep in mind that a lord was supposed to treat his vassals with respect and honor. This meant that he couldn’t ask for their advice and simply reject it if it didn’t suit him since that would not be showing his counselors the respect they deserved. Medieval councils were not rubber stamps [They didn't have rubber, in any event. It was one of the things that they discovered in the New World.]
So we have a meeting of the council to decide whether to attack Marsile of Zaragoza, send another ambassador to negotiate with him (he had chopped the last two ambassadors into little pieces and sent them back in a basket), or simply pack up and go home. When the council begins, Roland is the first to speak, arguing against going home even though the army has been in Spain for seven years and has gotten quite war-weary. Whoa! Roland is only about eighteen years old, a rather rash young man. It’s customary in council for the oldest and most experienced members to speak first, and Roland has just behaved in a very offensive manner. Of course, he is Charlemagne’s nephew, the son of Charlemagne’s sister, but that’s not good enough to excuse his action. Ganelon, as his stepfather, admonishes him, as it is a father’s (or a stepfather’s) duty to rein his son in when he is behaving badly. But Roland turns on Ganelon and simply ridicules him. Ganelon tells Roland that he has never shown the proper deference to his stepfather, a way of pointing out to the other members of the council that he is not responsible for his stepson’s lack of manners. Roland answers by insulting him even more viciously.
Something is obviously very wrong here, and whatever it is simply gets worse. The council is finally swayed into recommending another embassy. I don’t know about you, but I would not have relished the idea of being an ambassador to a man who had a record of chopping ambassadors up into little pieces. The members of the council volunteer one by one, and Charlemagne rejects them on the grounds that he can’t afford to lose them. Roland then volunteers his stepfather, and Charlemagne accepts the nomination. Ganelon flies into a rage and says that Roland is trying to get him killed. He then promises three times to take vengeance on Roland and his buddies if he gets out of this alive. Bad show! This sort of declaration, repeated three times is known as a “defiance” and is, according to the feudal law of the times, the start of a legitimate feud. If the person issuing the defiance succeeds in killing the person or persons whom he defies, or if he is killed by them, it will not be considered a crime but the resolution of a private matter. Of course, one is not allowed to issue a defiance in a court or council, but Charlemagne does nothing to stop it [except to say "tut, tut"]. So Charlemagne gives Ganelon a sealed letter to deliver to Marsile, outlining terms for a peace, and hands him the wand that will make Ganelon his herald and official representative. But the wand falls before Ganelon can get a grip on it, and he has to pick it up from the ground rather than receiving it from Charlemagne’s hand.
This episode sets in motion everything that follows, and it poses a lot of questions that you need to keep in mind if you’re ever going to figure out what’s actually going on. Why did Roland jump into the discussion out of turn and why didn’t Charlemagne call him to order after he simply laughed at his stepfather for trying to correct him? Why is Roland so intent on keeping the war going? How old is he, really — remember that the army has been in Spain for seven years. Why does Charlemagne reject everyone until he’s given the choice of Ganelon? Why does Ganelon suddenly claim that Roland is trying to kill him? Why doesn’t Charlemagne intervene and stop Ganelon’s defiance? If the council has been called to decide what to do, how come Charlemagne has a letter to Marsile already written and sealed? When the ceremony of the passing of the baton breaks down, why doesn’t Charlemagne simply start over again? Did Ganelon simply fumble the pass, or did Charlemagne drop the wand? If Charlemagne did drop the want, did he do in by accident or on purpose? What’s the big deal about it, anyway?
Like the writer of a mystery story, the author of The Song of Roland has given you a lot of clues that he expects you to follow up as you learn the rest of the story. And like the writer of a mystery story, the author has given you clues that seem to point in all sorts of directions. And, if you’ve read many good mysteries, you are probably aware that the most important clue might very well be something that the author did not say. That’s a good thing to keep in the back of your mind as you begin to read The Song of Roland. Is there something important that the author seems to have left out?
Другие работы по теме:
Being A Musician Essay Research Paper Music
Being A Musician Essay, Research Paper Music is an ever-changing style. People listen to music of all types everyday. What most people don’t know is what it takes to make that music they listen to. Today’s music is a lot different than music prior to the 80’s. Machines can almost do all the work for some of the songs you hear on the radio today, but there are still some groups who do it the real way.
Stand By Me Essay Research Paper Stand
Stand By Me Essay, Research Paper Stand By Me Stand By Me, is a film written in 1986, that focuses on the two day journey of four best friends. The music in the film is one that is mostly song scoring. The music in this film was chosen very well. It was even pop song scoring. This movie has two main examples of music that I would like to point out, starting with moodsetting, it then moves to song scoring.
Chivalric Songs Essay Research Paper Micro theme
Chivalric Songs Essay, Research Paper Micro theme Topic: Courtly songs off differing views of Chivalry, especially of Chivalric love. Contrast as specifically as possible, the views on chivalry in one of these pairs: #?s 2 & 4, #?s 6 & 7.
Culture From Adam Sandler
’s ‘What The Hell Happened To Me ‘ Essay, Research Paper How Music Affects Culture Adam Sandler?s “What the Hell Happened to Me?” This song means that culture affects how we grow up greater then most
Things They Carried Essay Research Paper In
Things They Carried Essay, Research Paper In the story ?Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong? in The Things they Carried by Tim O? Brian Mary Ann Bell goes from one end of the spectrum to the other.
Censorship Essay Research Paper CensorshipSince the beginning
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship Since the beginning of art and entertainment society has tried to censor the public from the so called ?influences? of art, television, movies, and music. Censorship is suppose to protect the children from seeing form of sex, violence, profanity and drugs. If its suppose to protect the children from seeing these thing why do I see so many children doing those things.
Eminem Guilty Conscience Analysis And Evaluation
Essay, Research Paper Guilty Conscience Analysis: The first part of the song is about Eddie who is a twenty-three year old man who is having problems and figures he can get money if he robs the liquor store his problems will be solved, but then he has second thought right before robbing it. Now his good conscience, which is Dre, makes Eddie think bout what will happen if he does rob the store and how much trouble he s going to get in if he does it.
The Role Of Women In The Song
Of Roland Essay, Research Paper The Role of Women in the Song of Roland Women are not mentioned often in the Song of Roland. They appear in only seventeen of almost three hundred laisses. It is because they are included so rarely, however, that the
Song Of Roland Comparision Essay Research Paper
The Song of Roland was the first French epic poem to be written down. What is the Song about? Explain the story and compare it (using examples) to two other epic poems or works that are similar
The Iliad And Song Of Roland Essay
, Research Paper The Iliad and Song of Roland: Attitudes Toward War The Iliad by Homer and Song of Roland are two enjoyable novels that both deal with the basic nature of war. They are set in different eras of history, but they both manage to depict the image of war and conquest very well. With that said, they do indeed share obvious plot characteristics.
My Own Prison By Creed Essay Research
? Paper Richie Lord 10/15/2000 ENC 1101 Song Lyrics What are they saying? “My Own Prison” by the group Creed is a very moving and inspirational song. The reason it is an inspirational song is because it has an excellent meaning. The author of the song Scott Sapp, one of the members of the band, had a hard life and is expressing his feeling about his life in this song.
Hanson Essay Research Paper Hanson
Hanson Essay, Research Paper Hanson’s first single came out in May of 1997, which was Mmmbop. The song swept over the nation. It quickly rose to number one within weeks. It stayed at number one for 8 weeks. Today, Hanson has a new album at called This Time Around! The songs on This Time around are: You Don’t Know, If Only, This Time Around, Runaway Run, Save Me, Dying to be Alive, Can’t Stop, Wish that I was There, Love Song, Sure About It, Hand in Hnad, In the City, A Song to Sing.
A Story About Seeing Mxpx Essay Research
Paper A story about seeing MxPx On November 13th I went to Tramps in New York to see one of my favorite bands, MxPx. MxPx is a Christian pop-punk band. Pop punk basically means happy punk. The band members, are Mike Herrera who plays bass and sings, Tom Wisniewski who plays guitar and Yuri Ruley plays drums. They played about 10 songs, all of which I knew.
Here In The Real World Essay Research
Paper The Real World In today s society the music industry bombards the public with songs containing various subject matter. Each song pertains to a different subject and each song has numerous meanings. All though every song means something diverse, we generalize and assume every style of music has to do with certain subjects.
About Love Essay Research Paper About Love
About Love Essay, Research Paper About Love This is how it starts: ?I will star to write a letter, about love and peaceful moments by your side?. ?About Love? it is the name of the song I am going to write about. Why is this song so important to me? It has to do mostly with my memories and feelings. The song reminds me a period of time in my life when I was not old enough to understand its meaning.
Songs For The Pearl Essay Research Paper
The Pearl Essay #8 I think this song well describes the feeling in the Book The Pearl at the time when Kino and Juana were walking home from the hill with a rifle and their dead baby, the song shows their pain, and they, in a sense are taking their lives on the ?otherside? (title of song) because once such a life influencing change is made in your life like that you are trapped on the ?otherside? of life and society, you are now the center of attention because of the way your life has so much changed.
Protest Songs Essay Essay Research Paper Protest
Protest Songs Essay Essay, Research Paper Protest Songs Essay Over the years, there have always been songs, and things to protest about. And what do you get when you put them together? You get…Protest Songs!! Protest songs have been around for almost for ever, song artists used and still use their music to voice their opinion against things, therefore making it a form of protest.
Comparison Between Gita Govinda And The Song
Of Solomon Essay, Research Paper Analysis and Comparison of Gita Govinda and Song of Solomon Gita Govinda is a religious love poem in the Indian religion. The poem consists of
The Theme Of Father Son Relationships In Beowulf
& The Song Of Roland Essay, Research Paper The Theme of Father/Son Relationships in Beowulf & The Song of Roland Thomas Lazzaro Professor Fisher Literary Patterns of European Development Paper
The Song Of Roland Essay Research Paper
The Song of Roland is the oldest known epic in France, dating from around the Twelfth Century AD. Telling the story of Charlemagne at Roncesvalles in 778, the events of The Song of Roland have been shifted into a modern (12th Century) setting, bringing a long history of concerns about Muslim invasion that gripped France in Charles Martel’s and Charlemagne’s time.
Song Of Myself Essay Research Paper Author
Song Of Myself Essay, Research Paper Author: Walt WhitmanTitle: Song of MyselfSummary: Song of Myself is a poem by Walt Whitman that encourages the inner-self and emphasizes the unity of all nature. Near the beginning, Whitman vividly describes how free he feels and states that everyone should experience it not at second or third hand.
Mxpx Essay Research Paper On November 13th
Mxpx Essay, Research Paper On November 13th I went to Tramps in New York to see one of my favorite bands, MxPx. MxPx is a Christian pop-punk band. Pop punk basically means happy punk. The band members, are Mike Herrera who plays bass and sings, Tom Wisniewski who plays guitar and Yuri Ruley plays drums. They played about 10 songs, all of which I knew.
Song Analysis
: “How Come, How Long” Essay, Research Paper Song How Come, How Long 1 There was a girl I used to know 2 She was oh so beautiful 3 But she’s not here anymore 4 She had a college degree
Analysis And Comparison Of Gita Govinda And
Song O Essay, Research Paper Analysis and Comparison of Gita Govinda and Song of SolomonGita Govinda is a religious love poem in the Indian religion. The poem consists ofmainly two characters, Krishna and Radha, who are estranged lovers. Towards the end ofthe poem, however, they are reunited, giving accounts of how they feel about each otheralong the way.
Robert Frost Essay Research Paper In Robert
Robert Frost Essay, Research Paper In Robert Frosts’ poem “The Road Not Taken,” Frost talks of choosing between two roads to travel. Frost has come to a split in the road and has to choose which road to pick. In Randy Travis’ song “I Told You So,” a man learns that his girlfriend is choosing between himself and another man.
Music I Like To Listen Essay Research
Paper There are many bands and different kinds of music I like to listen to. I like to listen to many different bands and songs. When I listen to music I listen for the beat as long as listen for the lyrics. Even with all the different types of music around I mainly like to listen to hard rock. I like to listen because of the hard guitars and the streaming drums.
Uncle Sams Song Essay Research Paper Uncle
Uncle Sam`s Song Essay, Research Paper Uncle Sam’s song, "I Don’t Ever Wanna See You Again" is a song about a guy who gets his heart broken by his girlfriend. In this song Uncle Sam is
White Rabbit Essay Research Paper The song
White Rabbit Essay, Research Paper The song I am reporting on is called White Rabbit . The band, Jefferson Airplane, performs the song. I selected this song because of the eerie feeling it gives you when you listen to it. Also, this song is a very good example of drug use among the youth, especially the hippies, in the 1960 s.
A Femme Fatal S Tragedy Essay Research
Paper A femme fatal s tragedy: Women s mundane life In “Siren Song Many of Margaret Atwood s heroines are independent, strong, and self serving. Those same characteristics are evident in “Siren Song.” In “Siren Song,” Margaret Atwood paints the picture of a mythical femme fatal who lures men to their deaths.
Adam
’s Song Essay, Research Paper Adam’s Song I never thought I?d die alone I laughed the loudest who?d have known? I trace the cord back to the wall No wonder it was never plugged in at all