– Shape Essay, Research Paper
“Shape is that which alone of existing things always follows color.”
“A shape is that which limits a solid; in a word, a shape is the limit of a solid.”In the play Meno, written by Plato, there is a point in which Meno asks that Socrates give a definition of shape. In the end of it, Socrates is forced to give two separate definitions, for Meno considers the first to be foolish. As the two definitions are read and compared, one is forced to wonder which, if either of the two, is true, and if neither of them are true, which one has the most logic. When comparing the first definition of shape: “that which alone of existing things always follows color,” to the second definition: “the limit of a solid”, it can be seen that the difference in meaning between the two is great. Not only in the sense that the first is stated simply and can be defended easily, while the later is more difficult to comprehend and back up; but also in the sense that the second would have to involve the defiance of mathematical theories and/or proofs in order to stand true, while the first does not. It should also be noted that in the first definition, the word “a” is never mentioned. Socrates is not making a statement about “a shape” or “a color”, but about shape and color themselves. In the definition given to please Meno, Socrates’ words are “a shape” and “a solid”. It can be taken from earlier discussions in the play that the second definition is simply a definition of a shape, rather than a definition of shape in and of itself.
In the simple sentence that Socrates originally gives to Meno, he has not given then definition of a shape, rather he has given the definition of the term shape. For example, if a person was asked what a triangle is, the response would most likely be that it is a shape, but shape would never be defined as shape itself. It is simply an object that falls under the category of shape. Therefore, in one sentence, Socrates has put a definition to shape, for without color there can be no shape, there could not even be a shape to fall under the category that would have once been known as “shape”. None of the examples that Socrates and Meno discussed could prove the definition false. If something is round, for instance, then it is a shape, and a shape cannot exist without color. Therefore, shape must be formed by color, proving that color must precede shape and that shape must proceed color. The same proves true of a square, trapezoid, cube, or any other shape that exists. For, a solid must have a specific area and volume, and the naked eye can tell that the solid is there and has color, because if it had no color it would not be visible, therefore it would not be known to exist. In order for a shape that is not a solid, such as a line, to be seen, it must be drawn or made visible in some other way. As soon as that occurs, color is what has formed it.
However, Socrates’ statement is also disputable. Take the matter of the geometric plane. It is not visible. It can be represented for any purpose by drawing it, but as soon as it is drawn, it is no longer a plane for restrictions have been put upon it. A plane continues infinitely in all directions. Although geometric planes cannot be seen, it is a mathematical fact that they exist, although it is not known for certain if they occupy a certain amount of space. Because it has these properties, it is indeed a shape, but it is a shape that cannot be seen, an infinite shape, and one that requires no color to be called so. But the mystery of the geometric plane in relationship to this definition has not been solved, for an object such as a circle cannot exist without a geometric plane, but a geometric plane can exist with an object. So, since it has been stated by Socrates that shape cannot exist without color, what should be said when a circle – existing solely because of color – is on a geometric plane? The geometric plane must exist, as the circle is on it and as the circle cannot exist without it, but is the plane considered a shape since it’s area is infinite? There is certainly the possibility that there are those who do not think of it as a shape because it has no restrictions put on it, but if this was so, why did Socrates not include this in his definition? It could have possibly been because by shape he meant objects with definite form.
There is the possibility that, in the mind of Socrates, his definition is unflawed, for it may have been that he did not view a geometric plane as a shape, but only as something that has an area which extends infinitely. If this was the case, then his statement is indisputable. However, if that was not the case, he may have stated it for the purpose of discovering how far he could stretch Meno’s logic. However, there is also the slight possibility that Socrates did not consider all of the options and examples that were filed under the category of shape, and therefore he could very well be wrong. In this situation it is difficult to tell how truthful this definition is, for what was going on in Socrates’ mind at that time cannot be known to us. It is for each to draw a conclusion from.
Then the question arises as to the truth and logic involved in Socrates’ second definition, which is given purely to please Meno. The problem that occurs when this statement is made is that it is mathematically impossible to have a finite number of shapes; therefore, there are an infinite amount of solids, meaning that a solid cannot be limited. A shape can look like anything; it can have any form, but the instant that even the smallest part of that shape is moved or shifted, it becomes a different shape altogether. Several examples exist that can prove this statement untrue. Take the word “round”, which Socrates used as an aid in an example that was given to Meno in a previous part of the text. A ball, for instance, is a round solid (round being any shape that has a circumference), so the conclusion can be reached that the ball is a solid and round is its shape, therefore the shape is limited by only the solidity of the ball. Thus, this does not support Socrates’ definition, for it shows that the shape is limited by the solid, not that the solid is limited by the shape. In addition to this, there is another dispute against this definition of shape using the word round. A circle is round, and yet it is not a solid. Therefore, this statement does not define the term shape; rather it defines on a certain type of shape, a solid shape.
The logic that Socrates had in stating his second answer in those particular terms could have been several. It would have followed the theme that is seen throughout the play of the Meno and Socrates mocking each other. Socrates knew that the answer that would please Meno the most would be the one that sounded the smartest but made the least amount of sense. However, Meno does not seem to realize this, and accepts Socrates’ answer. This should have made it especially interesting for Socrates, for he had agreed to give Meno this second definition in the form of Gorgias. Meno is always agreeing with him, and incorporates his points into many of the conversations that he tends to hold. Not only is Socrates secretly mocking Meno, he is also mocking Gorgias.
At first appearance, both definitions seem to hold some weight. However, upon further investigation, the second can be ruled out as truth altogether. The first holds much weight, and definitely contains a higher percentage of truth within it than the second. However, the debate about whether all shapes can fall under his original definition is still debatable; having many strong points, but one weak point. Nonetheless, the conclusion that, if one of the two had to be chosen as the truth, the first definition of Socrates would most certainly emerge victorious.
Другие работы по теме:
Plato Essay Research Paper PlatoPlato was born
Plato Essay, Research Paper Plato Plato was born about 429 BC. He came of an Athenian family that was aristocratic on both sides. His father, Ariston, was believed to have descended from the early kings of Athens. Perictione, his mother, was distantly related to the 6th- century BC lawmaker Solon. When Plato was a child, his father died, and his mother married Pyrilampes, who was an associate of the statesman Pericles.
Philosophy Questions Essay Research Paper SharaForman PHL
Philosophy Questions Essay, Research Paper SharaForman PHL 103 01 In looking at the development of Plato?s conception of knowledge through the mouthpiece of Socrates, one can see that philosophy is about questioning the limits of knowledge. The ever popular and reoccurring question that philosophers want to know is what is everything? The beliefs and ideas of Socrates were shared by all philosophers of their time.
Sor Juana Essay Research Paper Sor Juana
Sor Juana Essay, Research Paper Sor Juana In?s de Asbaje y Ram?rez de Santillana, naci? en 12 de noviembre de 1651 en San Miguel de Nepantla, Amecameca. Fue hija de padre vasco y madre mexicana. Toc?le en suerte vivir una ?poca en que la literatura nacional era copia, m?s o menos fiel, de la espa?ola; culteranisrno, estilo que se agudiza en gongorismo; y la tendencia de los escritores de ese tiempo a escribir ?nicamente en verso, la cual, por la estilizaci?n que prefer?an, cuajaba en composiciones que constitu?an verdaderos logogr?ficos del intelecto: se vest?a a la idea con un ropaje enfarragoso, para luego gozar en desnudarla.
Why Does Socrates Claim That No Person
Ever Desires What Is Bad? Essay, Research Paper Why Does Socrates claim that no person ever desires what is bad? The arguments to support the claim that Socrates believes that no man ever desires what is bad may be found in the Meno. In this conversation, Socrates and his fellow man Meno are in search of true knowledge (or the form) of virtue.
Can Plato Adequately Respond To Thrasymachus
’s Immoralist View Of Justice? Essay, Research Paper In Book 1 of the ‘Republic’, Socrates, in answer to the question ‘What is Justice?’ is presented with a real and dangerous alternative to what he thinks to be the truth about Justice. Julia Annas believes Thrasymachus thinks Justice and Injustice do have a real existence that is independent of human institutions; and that Thrasymachus makes a decided commitment to Injustice.
Meno Humans Can Become Virtuous Essay
, Research Paper Before reading the Meno I thought I had a clear definition of exactly what virtue meant. Once I read the dialogue I realized that I only have an idea of what virtue and being virtuous means. I definitely think that it has many aspects to it, including moderation, justice, effort, patience, knowledge and being able to live peacefully with others.
Dialogue Of Plato And Meno Essay Research
Paper Summary of Meno In the “Meno” dialogue, Meno asks Socrates if he knows how virtue is acquired: by nature, or by teaching. Socrates replies that one cannot know how virtue is acquired unless one has a solid definition of ‘virtue.’ Socrates then charges Meno with the task of offering him a sufficient and whole definition of what virtue really is.
THE MENO Essay Research Paper The Meno
THE MENO Essay, Research Paper The Meno asks the question ?what is virtue and can it be taught??. Meno?s conversation with Socrates is an attempt to know exactly what virtue means and how it can be defined to come to the decision of whether or not it
Ralph Vaughan Williams
– Symphony No 5 Essay, Research Paper Ralph Vaughan Williams – Symphony Number Five Ralph Vaughan Williams, descended from the famous Wedgwood and Darwin families, was born at Down Ampney, Gloucestershire in 1872. In 1890 he entered the Royal College of Music, and in 1892 he entered Trinity College, Cambridge.
Socrates Vs Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper Sarah
Socrates Vs. Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper Sarah Raske October 11, 2000 Socrates Vs. Gilgamesh Socrates? view of death in the Phaedo, Crito, and Apology is complex. His argument tries to prove that philosophers, of all people, are in the best state to die or will be in the best state after life because of the life they lead.
Hume Essay Research Paper In the Meno
Hume Essay, Research Paper In the Meno, Plato justifies the possibility for one s mind to uncover knowledge. Knowing one can obtain knowledge motivates the mind to gain more knowledge. Plato explains the theory of recollection by first questioning what virtue is, then demonstrating the process through the questioning of a slave boy.
Socrates A Closer Look At The Greatest
Thinker Essay, Research Paper Introduction Who is Socrates? Socrates was a Greek philosopher. He was the best of his time (400’s BC), and is considered one of the wisest people of all times. Also, he was the first of three of the greatest teachers of ancient Greece. He was born and died in Athens. He was a short philosopher, who wore only a white robe at all times and all seasons.
Adios Cordera Primo Distante De 1984 Essay
, Research Paper Chris Stone el 2 de diciembre, 1996 Ram?n D?az-Sol?s el 9o trabajo Adi?s, Cordera: primo distante de 1984 Adi?s, Cordera, un buen ejemplo del movimiento naturalista, nos cuenta una historia triste pero muy sencilla y pura. Su lenguaje descriptivo nos da una imagen perfecta de la escena presentada.
Monografa Tlatelolco 68 Essay Research Paper IntroduccinLa
Monograf?a Tlatelolco 68 Essay, Research Paper Introducci?n. La sociedad mundial hab?a dado un cambio enorme con la finalizaci?n de la Segunda guerra Mundial; en Latinoam?rica, especialmente, se intensifica el fen?meno de inmigraci?n del campo a la ciudad; es entonces cuando surge el coque generacional entre los padres, poseedores de valores rurales, y los hijos, espolvoreados con los valores urbanos adquiridos en el contexto.
Is Knowledge Worth Seeking Essay Research Paper
Socrates argued that actively seeking out knowledge leads to the ability of man to moderate his behavior accordingly. If one examines a situation thoughtfully, and from several angles, the most logical course of action will present itself. By exercising this method of reasoning a person becomes wise. Socrates would call this the ability to govern the qualities of your soul properly and it is undoubtedly what he sought.
Plato On Education Essay Research Paper Plato
Plato On Education Essay, Research Paper Plato, an Athenian philosopher, was the first man to present a theory of education. He was a student of Socrates who influenced much of his work. He is best known for his work entitled The Republic. The main question he entertained regarded justice. Within that discussion of justice, he examines his theory of education.
Chopin And Ravel Essay Research Paper Chopin
Chopin And Ravel Essay, Research Paper Chopin s Ballade is described as a story carried forward by its own momentum, leaping ahead or lingering over some details but never backtracking. While Ravel s Alborada del gracioso is a wild Spanish dance filled with leaps, twirls and excitement.
Socialism Essay Research Paper
“No les parece extra o que me tengan que declarar muerto una y otra y otra vez”, dice el personaje de Marx en una peque a obra de teatro escrita por Howard Zinn. La recurrente necesidad de darle el tiro de gracia a las teor as e interpretaciones hist ricas de Marx deja traslucir uno de sus conceptos claves: la lucha de clases.
Tango 2
Tango – In Spanish Essay, Research Paper “El tango tiene el poder de fundir a dos extra?os en uno solo, expresando a trav?s del baile sus deseos? los convierte en grandes amantes y h?roes, aunque sea por un breve momento. El tango es el susurro de la sensualidad que surge del ligero aroma de perfume. El tango es la glamour de un sal?n de baile y tambi?n el misterio de ese mundo que se encuentra debajo.
Method Of Argument And Theories Of Knowledge
Essay, Research Paper Jordan Chasnoff November 21, 2000 CORE 101 Socrates? Method of Argument and Theories of Knowledge The methods of argument used by Socrates in the works of Plato
St Augustine Confessions Essay Research Paper Saint
St. Augustine Confessions Essay, Research Paper Saint Augustine s Confessions Saint Augustine was believed to be the Christian Plato. He describes Plato with the adulation of an admirer and follower. He achieved most of his knowledge through the interpretations of the immensely popular neo-Platonists.
Kafka Essay Research Paper Franz Kafka was
Kafka Essay, Research Paper Franz Kafka was born in Prague, Bohemia, July 3, 1883 and died June 3, 1924 of tuberculosis at the age of 40. He came from a middle-class Jewish family. His father was a shopkeeper and tried to climb up the social ladder by working hard at his shop and sending Franz to a prestigious German high school.
Ignorance Is Not An Excuse Essay Research
Paper We only choose what we think is good and if anyone chooses evil it must be through ignorance. Ignorance is not an excuse Molly Schweiger Philosophy 110, Section 07 01
Virtue Essay Research Paper Paper 1VirtueDuring Dr
Virtue Essay, Research Paper Paper 1 Virtue During Dr. Martin Luther King s life, he tried to introduce virtues not only to African Americans, but to Caucasians too. Even though back then racism was very dramatic time period, we still see racism today. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. showed that how being virtuous can help solve problems of racism.
Theory Of Recollection Essay Research Paper Plato
Theory Of Recollection Essay, Research Paper Plato has had a Theory of Recollection to explain our access of knowledge, that knowledge is from within, and not obtained through experience. The Theory of Recollection refers to the idea that recollection is like the soul, where it is maintained and never dying, therefore it constitutes the spiritual aspect of remembering.
Epistemology Essay Research Paper Plato
Epistemology Essay, Research Paper Plato’s View in Human Knowledge Plato presents three different views about knowledge in Meno, Republic, and Theaetetus. In Meno’s case, Plato believes knowledge as something innate in us when we are born; in his later view, in Republic, Plato believes we perceive things and gain knowledge; and from the last view, in Theaetus, Plato believes knowledge is the combination of a true opinion and a rational opinion.
Plato And The Republic Essay Research Paper
Life Plato was born around the year 428 BCE into an established Athenian household with a history of political connections — including distant relations to both Solon and Pisistratus. Plato’s parents were Ariston and Perictone, his older brothers were Adeimantus and Glaucon, and his younger sister was Potone.
PlatoS Rejection Of Empiricism Paradox Essay Research
Paper One consequence of this view is Plato?s rejection of empiricism, the claim that knowledge is derived from sense experience. However, when one examines the scene in the Meno between Socrates and the slave boy in greater depth, one can see the flaws in this paradox. Plato uses Socrates? experiment, in which he draws one of Meno?s slaves out from the gathered crowd and proceeds to demonstrate the theory of recollection using geometry; however, this experiment?s purpose tests the credulity of the reader; and in some cases Socrates? questions are blatantly leading.One consequence of this view is Plato?s rejection of empiricism, the claim that knowledge is derived from sense experience.
Seeking True Wisdom Essay Research Paper Seeking
Seeking True Wisdom Essay, Research Paper Seeking True Wisdom Ignorance is a lack of knowledge and unawareness of the happenings of the world. Socrates believes that knowledge does not consist merely of factual details but also deals with self-understanding and justice. ?The Apology,? written by Plato, describes the defense Socrates gives at his trial in Athens.
Platonic Paradox Essay Research Paper Platonic ParadoxTo
Platonic Paradox Essay, Research Paper Platonic Paradox To research Plato s paradox in the Meno, we can first consult the definition of what platonism is. Websters defines platonism as “actual things are copies of transcendent ideas and that these ideas are the objects of true knowledge apprehended by reminiscence.” For this essay, we will assume that trancendency is- “that which is beyond comprehension”, and reminiscence as “past experience”.
Analisis De Un Seor Muy Viejo Con
Unas Alas Enormes Essay, Research Paper Analisis de ?Un se?or muy viejo con unas alas enormes? En el cuento, ?Un se?or muy viejo con unas alas enormes? M?rquez exhibe su opini?n sobre el mundo social y la desgracia en como olvide lo diferente o lo extra?o. Cuenta un cuento de un hombre viejo con alas que viene al pueblo, como reacciona el pueblo y sus interpretaciones del ?ngel. ?Un se?or muy viejo con unas alas enormes? es una obra que describe con imaginaci?n y simbolismo, una cr?tica social sobre la mentalidad en cuanto a ideas desaf?as.